Software

Best Membership Management Software For Clubs (8 Tools)

18 min read

Wild Apricot is the best membership management software for clubs for most volunteer run groups, because the $66 a month plan covers 100 contacts with a website, member directory and dues collection in one place. ClubExpress is the pick for larger clubs that want per member pricing, at 42 cents per active member per month with a $24 monthly minimum. The eight tools below compare price per member, dues collection, event tools and the volunteer time each one saves, so a club can pick the system its committee will actually use.

A club runs on volunteers, and volunteers run out of time. The membership secretary who tracks dues in a spreadsheet, emails renewal reminders by hand and updates the website on a Sunday night is doing three jobs that software should do. The right tool takes those three jobs away and gives the evening back.

The mistake most clubs make is buying for the biggest club they imagine instead of the club they run today. A 60 member gardening club does not need the system a 2,000 member trade association uses, and the price gap between the two runs from free to $4,500 a year. This guide sorts the eight tools by club size, so the choice fits the membership list in front of you.

The 8 Tools at a Glance

ToolMain jobBest forStarting price
Wild ApricotWebsite, dues and directory in oneSmall to mid-size clubs$66/mo
ClubExpressPer member pricing with eventsLarger clubs, per member billing42¢/member/mo
MemberClicksAssociation grade membership toolsTrade and professional clubs$3,500/yr
Join ItSimple dues and member managementSmall clubs starting out$29/mo
MembershipWorksFree tier for tiny clubsClubs under 50 membersFree to 50
CommunalModern dues and community toolsSocial and hobby clubs$75/mo
Glue UpMembership plus events and CRMClubs that run many eventsNot published
MemberPlanetDues, fundraising and messagingClubs that fundraise tooNot published

Best Pick by Job

Job typeFirst pickSecond toolWhy this pair works
Volunteer run club, under 100 membersWild ApricotJoin ItWild Apricot covers the website too, Join It is cheaper to start
Large club, wants per member billingClubExpressWild ApricotClubExpress scales by member, Wild Apricot charges by contact tier
Trade or professional associationMemberClicksGlue UpMemberClicks is built for associations, Glue Up adds events depth
Tiny club, no budget at allMembershipWorksJoin ItMembershipWorks is free to 50 accounts, Join It starts at $29
Social club that fundraisesMemberPlanetCommunalMemberPlanet covers fundraising, Communal covers community

A volunteer run club with under 100 members should start with Wild Apricot at $66 a month for 100 contacts. The plan includes a website builder, a member directory, online dues payment and event registration, so the club replaces three separate tools with one subscription. The committee stops emailing spreadsheets around, and the membership secretary stops spending Sunday nights on renewals.

A larger club should start with ClubExpress instead, because the per member price of 42 cents a month fits a club whose membership changes every season. A 200 member club pays about $84 a month, and a 500 member club pays about $210, so the cost follows the membership rather than jumping between tiers. That is the core test when you compare the best membership management software for clubs, because a tier jump at renewal time is the bill that surprises a committee.

Which Membership Software Is Best for a Small Club?

Wild Apricot is the best first pick for a small club, because the $66 a month plan covers 100 contacts with a website, dues collection, a member directory and event registration in one place. A club that currently pays for a website, a payment tool and a mailing list separately will often save money by moving to the single subscription, and the volunteers learn one system instead of three.

Join It is the better pick if the club only needs dues and member management and already has a website. The $29 a month starting price is less than half of Wild Apricot, and the setup takes an afternoon. The trade off is the missing website builder, so a club without a site will still need one, and the total cost rises once that is added.

MembershipWorks is the pick for a club with no budget at all. The free tier covers up to 50 accounts, which suits a tiny club that only needs a member list and dues tracking. The free plan is genuinely useful rather than a demo, and the club can pay for more features when it grows past fifty members.

The test that decides the best membership management software for clubs for a small group is the handover test. A club changes its membership secretary every year or two, and the new volunteer inherits whatever system the last one chose. Wild Apricot and Join It both pass that test, because a new volunteer can learn the admin screen in an afternoon. A tool that needs a manual and a training session will be abandoned at the next election, and the club will be back on a spreadsheet within a year.

How to Choose the Best Membership Management Software for Clubs

Start by counting members, not features. A club with 60 members fits Wild Apricot at $66 a month or MembershipWorks free, while a club with 600 members fits ClubExpress at about $252 a month on per member pricing. The member count decides the shortlist before any feature comparison, because the price models reward different sizes.

Next, check dues collection. The tool must take online payments, send renewal reminders automatically and handle failed cards without the treasurer chasing people by phone. Wild Apricot, ClubExpress and Join It all do this well, and a tool that cannot collect dues online is not a membership tool at all.

Then look at the website. The best membership management software for clubs often includes a website builder, because most clubs need a public page and a members only area in the same place. Finally, test the volunteer test. Hand the admin screen to the least technical committee member and ask them to add a new member. If they cannot do it in five minutes, the tool will not survive the next committee election.

Then check the event tools, because most clubs run events as well as memberships. The tool should handle event registration, ticket sales and attendance lists without a second product, and the event page should look like part of the club website rather than a bolted on form. ClubExpress and Glue Up are the strongest here, while Join It covers the basics and MembershipWorks keeps events simple. A club that runs a weekly quiz night and an annual dinner needs event tools every week, not once a year.

Renewal cycle showing the stages of a club membership renewal

The 8 Tools in Detail

The eight tools below cover free tiers for tiny clubs, per member pricing for large clubs and association grade systems for professional groups. Each one is judged on price, dues collection, event tools and the volunteer hours it saves.

1. Wild Apricot

Wild Apricot costs from $66 a month for 100 contacts, and the price rises with the contact count rather than the member count. The plan includes a website builder, a member directory, online dues payment, event registration and email newsletters, so a club can run its public face and its back office from one login. The mobile app lets committee members check the roster from the clubhouse.

The payment surcharge is the detail to watch. Wild Apricot adds a 20 percent surcharge when a club uses Stripe or PayPal instead of Personify Payments, which is the built in processor. A club that already takes payments through Stripe will pay a fifth more on every transaction, and that surcharge adds up across a year of dues.

The contact based pricing is also a trap for clubs with large mailing lists. A club with 100 members and 400 newsletter subscribers pays for 500 contacts, because the tier counts every contact in the database. It suits small to mid-size clubs that want one system for the website, the dues and the directory, and that are happy to use the built in payment processor.

Start with the free trial and import the real member list, then test the dues payment with two real members before you invite the whole club.

2. ClubExpress

ClubExpress charges 42 cents per active member per month, with a $24 a month minimum and a $150 one time setup fee. The price range runs from 30 to 42 cents depending on the plan, and the per member model means the cost follows the membership exactly. A 200 member club pays about $84 a month, and the platform covers dues, events, a website, a member directory and email.

The setup fee and the learning curve are the drawbacks. The $150 one time fee is small but real, and the admin screens carry more options than the simpler tools here, so a new volunteer needs a day to learn the system. The design is also plainer than Wild Apricot, which matters for a club that cares about its public website.

It suits larger clubs that want the bill to follow the membership. A club whose numbers swing by season pays less in a quiet month, and the per member model never punishes growth with a sudden tier jump.

Pay the setup fee only after the trial, and import the full member list first so the monthly figure is real before the committee votes.

3. MemberClicks

MemberClicks costs from $3,500 a year for the trade plan and $4,500 a year for the professional plan, which makes it the most expensive tool in this guide by a wide margin. The platform is built for associations, with membership tiers, certification tracking, committee management, event registration and a member directory that handles thousands of records. The support team knows association work, and the onboarding is hands on.

The price is the drawback for any club that is not a professional association. A social club paying $3,500 a year for membership software is spending more on the tool than on its annual program, and the feature depth will sit unused. The setup also takes weeks rather than days, because the system is configured to the association rather than switched on.

It suits trade and professional associations with hundreds of members and complex needs. Certification tracking, committee roles and tiered memberships are the features that justify the price, and a club without those needs should look at Wild Apricot instead.

Ask MemberClicks for a quote for your exact member count, and speak to two associations of similar size before you sign an annual contract.

4. Join It

Join It costs from $29 a month, and it covers member management, online dues payment, event registration and a member directory in a clean modern interface. The setup takes an afternoon, the pricing is simple, and the tool does the core membership jobs without the extra modules that clutter bigger platforms. A small club can be live before the next committee meeting.

The missing website builder is the gap. A club without a website still needs one, and the cost of a separate site plus Join It can pass the Wild Apricot price. The event tools are also lighter than ClubExpress, so a club that runs weekly events will find less depth here.

It suits small clubs that already have a website and only need dues and members managed. The $29 starting price is the cheapest paid plan in this guide, and the interface is the easiest for a new volunteer to learn.

Start the trial with the real member list and one dues payment, and check the renewal reminders work before you pay for the first month.

5. MembershipWorks

MembershipWorks is free for up to 50 accounts, which makes it the only genuinely free tool in this guide for a tiny club. The free tier covers a member directory, dues tracking and event registration, and the paid plans add more accounts and features as the club grows. The interface is simple, and the setup takes an hour rather than a day.

The 50 account ceiling is the limit. A club that grows past fifty members must pay, and the paid price is not as clearly published as the free tier, so the committee should confirm the figure before the club grows into it. The feature set is also thinner than Wild Apricot, with no website builder and lighter event tools.

It suits clubs under 50 members with no budget at all. A new club, a small hobby group or a village society can run its membership free, and pay only when the membership grows past the free tier.

Create the free account with the real member list today, and set a reminder to check the paid price when the club reaches forty members.

6. Communal

Communal costs $75 a month, and it pairs membership management with modern community tools. Members get a directory, dues payment, event registration and a community feed where the club shares news and photos, which suits a social or hobby club that wants its members talking to each other, not just paying dues. The design is the most modern in this guide.

The price is high for the feature set, because $75 a month buys less membership depth than Wild Apricot at $66. The platform is also newer, so the integration list is shorter and the support depth is still growing. A club that needs certification tracking or complex tiers will find less here.

It suits social and hobby clubs that value community as much as administration. The feed and the photos keep members engaged between meetings, which is the job a spreadsheet never did.

Run the trial with the committee first, and check whether the members actually use the community feed before you pay for a second month.

7. Glue Up

Glue Up combines membership management with events and a CRM, so a club that runs many events can manage members, registrations and follow up from one system. The event tools are the strongest in this guide, with ticketing, agendas and attendee messaging built in, and the CRM tracks every interaction a member has with the club.

Glue Up publishes no price on its main page, so the table shows no figure instead of a guess. The breadth is also the weight, because a club that only needs dues and a directory pays for event and CRM tools it will not use, and the setup takes longer than the simpler tools here.

It suits clubs that run many events a year. A professional group with monthly meetups and an annual conference will use the event depth every week, and the CRM keeps the follow up consistent.

Ask Glue Up for the price for your member count and event volume, and test the event registration with a real upcoming event before you buy.

8. MemberPlanet

MemberPlanet covers dues, fundraising and messaging in one place, which suits clubs that raise money as well as collect dues. Members can pay dues, donate to a campaign and receive club messages from the same system, and the fundraising tools track every gift back to the donor. MemberPlanet lists no price on its main page, so the table leaves the figure blank.

The fundraising focus is also the limit. A club that never fundraises pays for tools it will not use, and the membership features are thinner than Wild Apricot or ClubExpress. The interface is functional rather than polished, and the lack of a published price makes budgeting harder than it should be.

It suits clubs that fundraise alongside membership. A sports club raising money for new equipment, or a charity club running an annual appeal, will use the fundraising tools every month.

Request the price in writing for your member count, and run one small fundraising campaign in the trial before you commit the whole club.

Wild Apricot vs ClubExpress: Tier Pricing Against Per Member Pricing

Price is the first difference, and it depends entirely on the member count. Wild Apricot costs $66 a month for 100 contacts, while ClubExpress costs 42 cents per active member per month with a $24 minimum. A 100 member club pays $66 on Wild Apricot and $42 on ClubExpress, so ClubExpress wins. A 60 member club pays $66 on Wild Apricot and $25.20 on ClubExpress, so ClubExpress wins again, and the gap only grows as the club gets larger.

The website is the second difference. Wild Apricot includes a website builder that many clubs use as their public face, while ClubExpress includes a website too, but a plainer one that fewer clubs love. A club without a website gets more value from Wild Apricot, because the builder replaces a separate subscription, and that saving can outweigh the per member price gap.

The deciding factor is the contact count. Wild Apricot charges by contacts, so a club with 100 members and 400 newsletter subscribers pays for 500 contacts. ClubExpress charges by active members only, so the same club pays for 100. Pick ClubExpress if the club is large or has a big mailing list. Pick Wild Apricot if the club is small and needs the better website.

What Does Club Membership Software Cost per Month?

The honest range runs from free to about $375 a month, depending on the club. MembershipWorks is free to 50 accounts, Join It starts at $29 a month, Wild Apricot starts at $66 a month for 100 contacts, and Communal is $75 a month. ClubExpress is 42 cents per active member per month, so a 200 member club pays about $84 and a 500 member club pays about $210.

The association tools sit far above that range. MemberClicks starts at $3,500 a year for trade associations, which works out near $292 a month, and the professional plan at $4,500 a year works out near $375 a month. A social club should never pay association prices, and a trade association should never try to run on a $29 tool.

The hidden cost is the payment surcharge. Wild Apricot adds 20 percent when a club uses Stripe or PayPal instead of the built in processor, so a club collecting $5,000 in dues pays $1,000 extra if it keeps its old payment method. Always ask about surcharges before comparing headline prices.

The free tier deserves a warning too. MembershipWorks is free to 50 accounts, and that is a genuine saving for a tiny club, but a club that grows past fifty members must pay, and the paid price should be confirmed before the growth arrives. The best membership management software for clubs is the one the club can still afford at twice its current size, because a tool that forces a migration at the moment the club is growing is the wrong tool.

Can Members Pay Dues Online Without a Separate Payment Tool?

Yes, on every paid tool in this guide. Wild Apricot, ClubExpress, Join It, Communal and MemberClicks all take online dues payments, send renewal reminders automatically and handle failed cards. The member pays by card, the treasurer sees the payment in the dashboard, and the renewal reminder goes out without anyone sending an email.

The difference is the surcharge and the processor. Wild Apricot charges 20 percent extra when a club uses Stripe or PayPal instead of Personify Payments, which is the built in option. ClubExpress and Join It are more flexible on the processor, so a club that already takes payments through Stripe should check the surcharge before it commits.

The other difference is the reminder flow. The best membership management software for clubs sends the reminder, then a second reminder, then a final notice, and marks the member as lapsed only after the third attempt. A tool that sends one reminder and stops leaves the treasurer chasing people by phone, which is the job the software was bought to remove.

A 6-Week Club Migration Checklist

Week one is the list. Export the member list from the spreadsheet, clean the duplicates, and count the active members, the lapsed members and the newsletter subscribers separately. Week two is the choice. Pick the tool that fits the member count, confirm the price including any payment surcharge, and get the committee to vote on it.

Week three is the import. Load the member list into the new tool, set up the dues amounts and the renewal dates, and test the payment with two committee members. Week four is the soft launch. Invite the committee and the ten most active members, and fix every problem they find before the wider launch.

Week five is the launch. Email every member with the new login, the dues link and a one page guide. Week six is the cleanup. Mark the lapsed members, archive the old spreadsheet, and confirm the first renewal reminders go out on schedule. A club that follows this plan migrates in six weeks without losing a member.

One warning applies to every week of the plan. Never delete the old spreadsheet until the new system has run one full renewal cycle, because the old list is the backup if the import misses a member. A club that deletes the spreadsheet in week one discovers the missing members in week five, when the renewal reminders go out and the phone starts ringing.

Club members working together in a community garden

Frequently Asked Questions

How much does Wild Apricot cost per month?

Wild Apricot costs from $66 a month for 100 contacts, and the price rises with the contact count. The plan includes a website builder, a member directory, online dues payment and event registration. Using Stripe or PayPal instead of the built in processor adds a 20 percent surcharge.

Is ClubExpress cheaper than Wild Apricot?

Yes, for most clubs. ClubExpress charges 42 cents per active member per month, so a 100 member club pays $42 against $66 on Wild Apricot, and a 200 member club pays $84. The gap grows with the member count, and ClubExpress charges by active members only, not by newsletter contacts.

Can a tiny club manage members for free?

Yes. MembershipWorks is free for up to 50 accounts, covering a member directory, dues tracking and event registration. A club that grows past fifty members must pay, so confirm the paid price before the club reaches forty members.

Does MemberClicks suit a social club?

No. MemberClicks starts at $3,500 a year for trade associations and $4,500 a year for professional plans, which is far more than a social club should pay. A social club should use Wild Apricot at $66 a month or ClubExpress at 42 cents per member, and save the difference for the club program.

How long does it take to move a club to new software?

Six weeks is realistic for a small club, following the checklist in this guide. Week one cleans the list, week three imports it, week five launches to members, and week six cleans up. A large association on MemberClicks should allow longer, because the setup is configured rather than switched on.

What happens to lapsed members in membership software?

The tool marks them lapsed after the renewal reminders fail, and the committee can see the lapsed list in one place. The best membership management software for clubs keeps the lapsed record, so the club can invite them back next season instead of losing their details.

Our Verdict for Clubs of Every Size

A tiny club should start free on MembershipWorks, and pay only when it grows past fifty members. A small volunteer run club should take Wild Apricot at $66 a month, because the website, the dues and the directory in one place save the most volunteer hours. A large club should take ClubExpress at 42 cents per member, because the bill follows the membership and never jumps a tier at renewal time.

A trade or professional association should take MemberClicks, because the certification and committee tools justify the $3,500 a year price. Pick the tool that fits the member count in front of you, migrate in six weeks, and let the volunteers have their Sunday nights back.

Leave a Comment