Aplos is the best church accounting software for most small and mid sized churches, because the Lite plan at $79 a month covers true fund accounting, donation tracking and contribution statements in the cloud. PowerChurch Plus is the pick for churches that want a one time purchase with payroll built in. The fifteen tools below compare fund accounting, payroll, donation tracking and price, so a church can pick the system its treasurer will actually close the books in.
Church accounting is different from business accounting. Every gift has to stay in the fund the donor or the board intended, the year end contribution statement has to meet IRS acknowledgment rules, and the finance committee wants balances by fund rather than one bank balance. A general accounting tool that cannot track funds will force the treasurer to keep the real books in a spreadsheet, which defeats the purpose of buying software at all.
The buying problem is that the market splits into church specific tools and general tools, and the general tools look cheaper until the fund accounting gap appears. This guide covers both groups, and says plainly which tools do true fund accounting, which ones run clergy payroll, and which ones publish a price.
The 15 Tools at a Glance
| Tool | Main job | Best for | Starting price |
|---|---|---|---|
| Aplos | Cloud fund accounting | Small and mid sized churches | $79 a month |
| PowerChurch Plus | All in one church system | Churches wanting a one time buy | $445 one time |
| ShelbyNext Financials | Enterprise church finance | Large multi campus churches | Quote-based |
| QuickBooks Online | General accounting | Churches with a bookkeeper | $35 a month |
| Xero | General cloud accounting | Small churches, simple books | $15 a month |
| ACS Realm | Church management and accounting | Churches on ACS already | Quote-based |
| Breeze | Church management, Tithely | Churches wanting one flat price | $72 a month |
| Church Windows | Church accounting and membership | Small churches, simple needs | Quote-based |
| IconCMO | Church management and finance | Mid sized churches | Quote-based |
| Servant Keeper | Donation and church management | Churches tracking donors | Quote-based |
| Tithe.ly | Giving and church management | Churches focused on giving | Quote-based |
| Pushpay | Giving and engagement | Large churches, mobile giving | Quote-based |
| FellowshipOne | Church management suite | Large churches, many campuses | Quote-based |
| ChurchTrac | Church management and accounting | Small churches on a budget | $29 a month |
| Wave | Free general accounting | Tiny churches, zero budget | Free |
Best Pick by Job
| Job type | First pick | Second tool | Why this pair works |
|---|---|---|---|
| Small church, true fund accounting | Aplos | ChurchTrac | Aplos is the fund leader, ChurchTrac is the budget fallback |
| Church wanting a one time buy | PowerChurch Plus | Aplos | PowerChurch is owned outright, Aplos is the cloud alternative |
| Large multi campus church | ShelbyNext Financials | ACS Realm | ShelbyNext is enterprise grade, Realm adds the management suite |
| Church with a bookkeeper | QuickBooks Online | Xero | QuickBooks is the standard, Xero is the simpler cloud option |
| Church focused on giving | Tithe.ly | Pushpay | Tithe.ly covers giving and management, Pushpay leads mobile giving |
A small church that wants true fund accounting should start with Aplos. The Lite plan costs $79 a month, Core costs $129 and Advanced costs $229, with fund accounting and contribution statements included on every tier and fund budgeting on Advanced. Payroll runs through a Gusto partnership rather than inside Aplos, which is the one gap to plan around, though the donation tracking and the reporting are the strongest in this guide for a small church.
A church that wants to own its software outright should start with PowerChurch Plus instead. The desktop licence costs $445 as a one time purchase, while PowerChurch Online costs $47 a month or $499 a year for two concurrent users. The payroll is built in with housing allowance tracking, W-2 and 941 printing, which is the feature Aplos lacks.
Which Church Accounting Tool Fits a 150 Member Church Best?
Aplos fits a 150 member church best, because the Lite plan at $79 a month covers fund accounting, donation tracking and contribution statements for a congregation of that size, with support and training free. The cloud access means the treasurer and the pastor can both see the books from anywhere, and the fund structure keeps every gift in the fund the donor intended without a spreadsheet on the side.
ChurchTrac is the better pick if the 150 member church is on a tight budget, because the price runs from $29 a month for 75 names to $119 a month for unlimited names, with 10 percent off annual billing. The fund accounting and the contribution statements are included on all tiers, though payroll is not built in and the church tracks payroll entered from a separate system. The setup help costs from $399 as an optional add on, which is worth knowing before the trial.
PowerChurch Online is the third option for a 150 member church that wants payroll built in, because $47 a month for two concurrent users covers the treasurer and the pastor, with housing allowance tracking included. That trade is the heart of choosing the best church accounting software for a small congregation, because the payroll question decides the shortlist before the price does.
How to Choose the Best Church Accounting Software
Start by checking the fund accounting. Aplos, PowerChurch Plus and ShelbyNext Financials all do true fund accounting with separate funds and fund level reporting, while QuickBooks Online and Xero are general tools that need workarounds to track funds. A church that buys a general tool expecting fund accounting will keep the real books in a spreadsheet, so the fund test comes first and the price comes second.
Next, check the clergy payroll. PowerChurch Plus includes payroll with housing allowance tracking, ACS Realm lists payroll with ministry specific details, and ShelbyNext Financials lists payroll with tax calculation. Aplos and ChurchTrac do not calculate payroll themselves, so a church with paid clergy needs a second system or a different tool, and that gap has to be priced before the decision.
Then check the contribution statements. Aplos, PowerChurch Plus and ChurchTrac all produce year end statements that meet IRS acknowledgment rules, with PowerChurch offering five statement layouts with email delivery. Finally, check the price at the real size, because ChurchTrac prices by names, Aplos prices by tier, and PowerChurch Online prices by concurrent users, so the same church pays a different price on each model.

The 15 Tools in Detail
The fifteen tools below cover church specific fund accounting, general accounting and giving focused platforms. Each one is judged on fund accounting, payroll, contribution statements and price, so this roundup of the best church accounting software stays honest about the general tool gap.
1. Aplos
Aplos is the cloud fund accounting platform built for small and mid sized nonprofits and churches, with more than 40,000 organisations on the platform. The Lite plan costs $79 a month, Core costs $129 and Advanced costs $229, with fund accounting and contribution statements included on every tier and fund budgeting on Advanced. Donation tracking, donor relationships and reporting are built in, and support and training are free.
The limit is the payroll. Aplos does not price its own payroll and points customers to its Gusto partnership, so a church with paid clergy pays for a second system. The price also rises fast between tiers, from $79 to $229, and a church that needs fund budgeting has to take Advanced.
2. PowerChurch Plus
PowerChurch Plus is the all in one church system sold as a desktop licence or online, with accounting, membership, events and payroll in one program. The desktop licence costs $445 as a one time purchase, while PowerChurch Online costs $47 a month or $499 a year for two concurrent users. The platform lists multiple accounting funds with separate parallel running charts of accounts, 35 fund accounting reports, budgets, five contribution statement layouts with email delivery, and payroll with housing allowance tracking.
The limit is the age of the interface and the concurrent user model. The desktop version is installed locally and shared on the local network, which suits a church with one office and not a church with a remote team.
It suits churches that want payroll built in and a one time purchase. The housing allowance tracking and the one time price are the features no other tool here matches together.
3. ShelbyNext Financials
ShelbyNext Financials is the enterprise church finance platform for large multi campus churches, denominational headquarters and ministries. The platform lists general ledger, payroll with tax calculation, fixed assets, purchasing and GAAP compliant reporting, with fund accounting and budgeting for complex financial structures. Pricing is not published, with third party listings reporting a starting price near $79 a month, though the vendor does not publish a price list and the church has to ask.
The limit is the quote only pricing and the enterprise weight. A small church will find more system than it needs, and the implementation follows the enterprise timeline rather than the church timeline.
It suits large multi campus churches and denominational offices. The GAAP compliant reporting and the payroll depth are the strongest in this guide for a big church.
4. QuickBooks Online
QuickBooks Online is the general accounting standard, starting at $35 a month for Simple Start, and it is the tool most bookkeepers already know. The platform covers invoicing, expenses, bank reconciliation and reporting, with a deep integrations list and an accountant network that makes hiring help easy. A church with a bookkeeper who already uses QuickBooks will save the training time entirely.
The limit is the fund accounting. QuickBooks is a general tool, and tracking funds needs classes or workarounds that a church specific tool handles natively.
It suits churches with a bookkeeper and simple finances. The familiarity and the accountant network are the reasons to choose it, and the price is fair for what it does.
5. Xero
Xero is the general cloud accounting platform, starting at $15 a month for the Early plan, with invoicing, bank reconciliation and reporting in a clean interface. The platform is simpler than QuickBooks and easier for a volunteer treasurer to learn, with a mobile app that handles expenses on the go. The price is the lowest among the general tools in this guide.
The limit is the same as QuickBooks, because Xero is a general tool without true fund accounting. A church with several funds will need workarounds, and the payroll is an add on rather than built in.
It suits small churches with simple books and a volunteer treasurer. The clean interface and the $15 price are the combination that makes it the best general tool for a tiny church.
6. ACS Realm
ACS Realm is the church management and accounting suite from ACS Technologies, covering Realm Accounting and ACS Financials in one system. The platform describes a double entry system that adheres to nonprofit accounting standards, with fund accounting, payroll with ministry specific details for pastors and leaders, and donor tax statements. Pricing is not published, and the church has to ask.
The limit is the quote only pricing and the suite weight. A small church will find more system than it needs, and the price is unknown until the sales call, which makes budgeting harder.
It suits churches already on ACS that want accounting inside the suite. The ministry specific payroll and the donor statements are the features that justify the suite price.
7. Breeze
Breeze, now offered as Tithely Church Management powered by Breeze, is the church management platform with a flat $72 a month price and a 30 day free trial. The platform covers membership, giving, events and communication in one place, with accounting features alongside the management tools. The flat price is simple for a treasurer to budget, because it never rises with the list size.
The limit is the accounting depth. Breeze is a management platform first and an accounting platform second, so a church that needs deep fund accounting will find Aplos or PowerChurch stronger. The value is the flat price and the simplicity, and a small church that wants one system for everything will feel the benefit.
It suits churches that want one flat price for management and basic accounting. The simplicity and the flat $72 are the reasons to choose it.
Trial it with the real membership list, because the import quality decides the fit.
8. Church Windows
Church Windows is the church accounting and membership platform for small churches with simple needs, covering accounting, membership, donations and scheduling in one system. The platform is built for a small church office, with a straightforward interface and a focus on the jobs a small congregation actually does. The vendor lists no public price, so the church has to request a quote.
The limit is the quote only pricing and the smaller feature set compared with Aplos or PowerChurch. A growing church will outgrow Church Windows, and the integrations list is thinner than the leaders. The value is the simplicity, and a church with one treasurer and one office will find it enough.
It suits small churches that want accounting and membership in one simple system. The straightforward design is the reason to choose it.
Ask for a written quote before the trial, because the price is unknown until the sales call.
9. IconCMO
IconCMO is the church management and finance platform for mid sized churches, covering accounting, membership, donations and reporting in one cloud system. The platform handles fund accounting, contribution statements and the finance committee reporting that a mid sized church needs, with a cloud interface that works from anywhere. Pricing comes by quote only, with no figure published on the vendor site.
The limit is the quote only pricing and the mid market focus. A small church will find more system than it needs, and a large church will find less depth than ShelbyNext, so IconCMO sits in the middle and the fit depends on the church size. The value is the balance, because the accounting and the management are equally strong.
It suits mid sized churches that want accounting and management in one cloud system. The balance of features is the reason to choose it.
Ask for a reference church of similar size, because the fit depends on the size.
10. Servant Keeper
Servant Keeper is the donation and church management platform, built around donor tracking, contribution statements and membership in one system. The platform covers the donor side deeply, with giving history, pledge tracking and statement generation, plus the accounting features a church needs to close the books. No published price exists, and the church has to ask the vendor directly.
The limit is the quote only pricing and the donor focus. A church that needs deep fund accounting will find Aplos stronger, and Servant Keeper is at its best when the donor tracking is the main job. The value is the donor depth, and a church with many donors and many pledges will use the features daily.
It suits churches that track donors and pledges closely. The donor depth and the statement generation are the features that make it the best donor pick in this guide.
Ask for a demo of the pledge tracking specifically, because that is where it beats the rivals.
11. Tithe.ly
Tithe.ly is the giving and church management platform, covering online giving, text giving, membership and accounting in one system. The platform is built for churches that want giving at the centre, with a giving app, kiosk giving and online giving pages, plus the management tools around them. The platform is priced on request, with no list price on the vendor site.
The limit is the giving focus and the quote only pricing. A church that needs deep fund accounting will find Aplos stronger, and Tithe.ly is at its best when the giving flow is the main job. The value is the giving experience, and a church with a mobile first congregation will feel the benefit immediately.
It suits churches focused on giving and mobile donations. The giving app and the text giving are the features that make it the best giving pick in this guide.
Check the giving fees separately from the platform price, because the fees are the real cost.
12. Pushpay
Pushpay is the giving and engagement platform for large churches, with mobile giving, engagement tools and analytics in one system. The platform is built for a large congregation that gives on phones, with a polished mobile experience and the reporting a large finance team needs. Pricing is quote only, and the vendor publishes no starting figure.
The limit is the large church focus and the quote only pricing. A small church will find more system than it needs and a price it cannot see until the sales call, so Pushpay suits a large church with a budget to match. The value is the mobile giving experience, which is the best in this guide for a large congregation.
It suits large churches with a mobile first congregation. The giving experience and the analytics are the reasons to choose it.
Ask for the giving fee schedule in writing, because the platform price is only part of the cost.
13. FellowshipOne
FellowshipOne is the church management suite for large churches with many campuses, covering membership, giving, accounting and reporting in one enterprise system. The platform handles multi campus structures, complex funds and large donor lists, with the depth a large church needs. The suite is sold by quote, with no price listed publicly.
The limit is the enterprise weight and the quote only pricing. A small or mid sized church will find more system than it needs, and the implementation follows the enterprise timeline. The value is the scale, and a church with five campuses and ten thousand members will use the features a small church never touches.
It suits large multi campus churches. The scale and the multi campus support are the reasons to choose it.
Ask for a reference church with the same campus count, because the fit depends on the scale.
14. ChurchTrac
ChurchTrac is the church management and accounting platform for small churches on a budget, with prices from $29 a month for 75 names to $119 a month for unlimited names, plus 10 percent off annual billing. The platform includes fund accounting and contribution statements on all tiers, with an optional accounting setup from $399. Payroll is not built in, and the church tracks payroll entered from a separate system.
The limit is the payroll gap and the smaller feature set compared with Aplos. A church with paid clergy needs a second system for payroll, and the reporting is lighter than PowerChurch. The value is the price, because $29 a month is the cheapest church specific accounting in this guide, and the fund accounting is real rather than a workaround.
It suits small churches on a tight budget that want true fund accounting. The $29 price and the fund accounting are the combination that makes it the best budget pick in this guide.
Start on the $29 tier, and confirm the name count before the trial ends.
15. Wave
Wave is the free general accounting platform, with invoicing, expenses and reporting at no cost for a tiny church. The platform covers the basic books well, with a clean interface and a mobile app, and the price is the whole story, because a church with zero budget can keep proper books from day one. The paid add ons cover payroll and payments, though the core accounting is free.
The limit is the fund accounting and the general tool design. Wave is a general platform without true fund accounting, so a church with several funds will need workarounds, and the support is thinner than the paid tools. The value is the price, and a tiny church with one fund and no payroll will find Wave enough.
It suits tiny churches with zero budget and simple books. The free price and the clean interface are the reasons to choose it.
Use Wave only if the church has one fund, because multiple funds need a church specific tool.
Aplos vs PowerChurch Plus. Cloud Fund Accounting Against a One Time Buy
The pricing difference is the first split. Aplos Lite costs $79 a month, so $948 a year, while PowerChurch Plus desktop costs $445 once and PowerChurch Online costs $47 a month. Over three years Aplos costs $2,844, PowerChurch desktop costs $445, and PowerChurch Online costs $1,692, so the one time buy is dramatically cheaper for a church that can live with a desktop system.
The payroll difference is the second split. PowerChurch Plus includes payroll with housing allowance tracking, while Aplos points customers to its Gusto partnership and charges for a second system. A church with paid clergy should take PowerChurch, because the payroll gap in Aplos costs more than the price difference, while a church with no paid clergy should take Aplos for the cloud access and the fund reporting.
The deciding factor is the team location and the payroll. A church with one office and paid clergy should take PowerChurch Plus, because the one time price and the payroll are unbeatable together. A church with a remote team and no payroll should take Aplos, because the cloud access matters more than the price.
What Does Church Accounting Cost a Small Congregation?
The honest answer is $0 to $229 a month, depending on the tool and the size. Wave costs nothing, ChurchTrac costs from $29 a month, Xero costs from $15 a month, QuickBooks Online costs from $35 a month, PowerChurch Online costs $47 a month, Breeze costs $72 a month, and Aplos costs from $79 a month to $229 for Advanced. ShelbyNext, ACS Realm, IconCMO, Servant Keeper, Tithe.ly, Pushpay, FellowshipOne and Church Windows are quote based, so the church has to ask.
The pricing model is the cost driver most churches miss. ChurchTrac prices by names, PowerChurch Online prices by concurrent users, Aplos prices by tier, and Breeze charges a flat $72 regardless of size. A church with 150 members pays $29 a month on ChurchTrac for 75 names only if the list is under 75, so the real price depends on the name count, and the treasurer should confirm the count before the trial.
The cheapest honest path for a small church is ChurchTrac at $29 a month, because the fund accounting is real and the price is the lowest among the church specific tools.
How Do You Switch Church Accounting Without Losing a Fund?
Days one to fourteen are the audit. List every fund, every donor and every open pledge, and confirm the fund balances in the old system before anything moves, because a migration that loses a fund balance creates a finance committee problem that lasts for years. Export the contribution history and the donor list, and check the totals against the bank statement.
Days fifteen to thirty are the move. Set up the funds in the new system first, then import the donors and the balances, and run the first contribution statements in both systems to compare them line by line. A statement that differs by even a dollar has to be investigated before the switch, because the IRS acknowledgment rules leave no room for a rounding error.
Days thirty to sixty are the cutover. Close one month in the new system, keep the old system open for the prior year, and do not cancel the old licence until the year end statements are produced from the new system. The overlap costs one extra month of the old licence, and that month is the cheapest insurance a church can buy when the best church accounting software has to prove itself on real money.

Frequently Asked Questions
Does QuickBooks do fund accounting for churches?
Not natively. QuickBooks Online is a general accounting tool starting at $35 a month, and tracking funds needs classes or workarounds that a church specific tool handles directly. A church with several funds should take Aplos or PowerChurch Plus instead, because the fund accounting is built in rather than bolted on.
Which church accounting software includes payroll?
PowerChurch Plus includes payroll with housing allowance tracking, and the desktop licence costs $445 once while the online version costs $47 a month. ACS Realm and ShelbyNext Financials also list payroll, while Aplos and ChurchTrac do not calculate payroll themselves and need a second system like Gusto for that job.
What is the cheapest church accounting software?
ChurchTrac is the cheapest church specific option at $29 a month for 75 names, with fund accounting included on all tiers. Wave is free, though it is a general tool without true fund accounting. The cheapest honest path with real fund accounting is ChurchTrac, which is the test of the best church accounting software for a small church.
Is Aplos worth $79 a month for a small church?
Yes, for a church that wants true fund accounting in the cloud. The Lite plan at $79 a month covers fund accounting, donation tracking and contribution statements, with support and training free. A church with no payroll and a remote team will feel the value, while a church with paid clergy should weigh the Gusto partnership cost alongside it, because that is the gap in the best church accounting software for a small church.
Can a church use Wave for free?
Yes. Wave is free for general accounting, with invoicing, expenses and reporting at no cost. The limit is the fund accounting, because Wave is a general tool without true fund tracking, so a church with several funds will outgrow it. A tiny church with one fund and no payroll can run on Wave indefinitely.
How long does it take to switch church accounting software?
A careful switch takes 30 to 60 days, with two weeks for the fund audit, two weeks for the move and the statement comparison, and a month for the first close in the new system. The old licence should stay open until the year end statements are produced from the new system, because cancelling early is the mistake that loses a fund balance.
The Church Accounting Pick for Your Congregation Size
A small church with a volunteer treasurer should take Aplos Lite at $79 a month, because the fund accounting and the cloud access are the best combination in this guide. A church on a tight budget should take ChurchTrac from $29 a month, a church with paid clergy should take PowerChurch Plus at $445 once, and a large multi campus church should take ShelbyNext Financials. A tiny church with zero budget should take Wave, and every church should audit the funds before signing.
The fund list is the first thing to get right. List the funds first, check the payroll gap second, and confirm the price at the real name count before the trial ends. An accounting system is a trust tool for the congregation, and the right one is the one that produces a clean contribution statement on the first try, which is the real test of the best church accounting software.