Software

Best Donor Management Software For Churches (15 Tools)

20 min read

The best donor management software for churches in 2026 puts Tithe.ly first for most congregations, because online giving costs nothing per month and card gifts process at 2.9 percent plus 30 cents. A small church that needs to receive tithes online, a midsize church that needs year end statements and a multisite church that needs one donor record across campuses all need the same thing, which is a system that treats every gift with care and every giver with respect. The fourteen tools below differ on whether they lead with giving, with church management or with accounting.

Donor management in a church is not fundraising software. A charity chases new donors, while a church serves people it already knows, records their gifts faithfully and produces statements they can trust at tax time.

The second test is the fee. A church that receives 500,000 dollars a year online will pay very different totals depending on the card rate, since Planning Center Giving at 2.15 percent plus 30 cents costs far less than a platform at 2.9 percent on the same volume.

The 15 Tools at a Glance

ToolMain jobBest forStarting price
Tithe.lyOnline giving with church managementMost churches that lead with givingGiving free, 2.9 percent plus 30 cents per card gift
Planning Center GivingGiving inside the Planning Center suiteChurches already running Planning CenterFree to 10 donations a month, 2.15 percent plus 30 cents
PushpayGiving, church management and app in oneGrowing and multisite churchesQuote based
BreezeSimple flat rate church managementSmall churches that want one simple database72 dollars a month flat
ChurchTracAll in one management with accountingSmall churches that want accounting includedFrom 29 dollars a month
RealmChurch management by ACS TechnologiesChurches that want a full ACS suiteQuote based
AplosFund accounting with donor managementChurches that need deep accountingFrom 79 dollars a month
DonorPerfectDonor management and fundraisingChurches that run campaigns and appealsQuote based
BloomerangDonor retention and engagementChurches that want to keep givers givingQuote based
Little Green LightSimple donor databaseSmall churches that want a simple donor recordReported from 45 dollars a month
GivelifyMobile first giving appChurches whose givers prefer a phone appFree, 2.9 percent plus 30 cents per gift
Subsplash GivingGiving inside the Subsplash platformChurches that want app, media and giving togetherBundled, reported from 80 dollars a month
EasyTitheOnline and text givingChurches that want simple text to giveQuote based
ShelbyNextChurch management with givingChurches that want a full management suiteQuote based
DonorSnapDonor management with online formsSmall nonprofits and churches that want formsReported from 39 dollars a month

Best Pick by Job

Job typeFirst pickSecond toolWhy this pair works
Free online giving to startTithe.lyGivelifyTithe.ly leads on features and Givelify adds a mobile first app
Lowest cost on high volumePlanning Center GivingTithe.lyPlanning Center Giving leads on card rate and Tithe.ly adds a free start
One platform for a growing churchPushpayPlanning CenterPushpay leads on the unified app and Planning Center adds modular choice
Simple flat rate managementBreezeChurchTracBreeze leads on simplicity and ChurchTrac adds accounting
Deep fund accountingAplosChurchTracAplos leads on accounting depth and ChurchTrac adds a lower price

A small church and a multisite church ask for opposite things from a donor tool. The small church needs a simple gift record, a statement at year end and a price that fits a modest budget, while the multisite church needs campus reporting, a branded app and a donor record that follows a giver across locations.

Giving volume decides the second cut. A church that receives 50,000 dollars a year online will barely notice the difference between a 2.15 percent and a 2.9 percent card rate, while a church that receives 500,000 dollars will save thousands a year on the lower rate.

Which donor tool is best for a small church?

Tithe.ly is the best pick for a small church because giving costs nothing per month to start. Card gifts process at 2.9 percent plus 30 cents and bank gifts at 1 percent plus 30 cents, with text to give, app giving, kiosk giving and stock gifts included, and no setup fee or contract. A small church can receive its first online gift the same week it signs up, which is the speed a volunteer run finance team needs.

ChurchTrac takes a different route to the same church, with all in one management that starts at 29 dollars a month and includes fund accounting in every plan. It suits a small church that wants one bill for people, giving, accounting and statements, rather than a free giving tool plus a separate management system. The trade is giving polish, since ChurchTrac giving is solid but less refined than Tithe.ly.

The honest test is a month of real gifts. Run the trial with the actual congregation, count how many givers use the online form, and check that the year end statement matches the bank deposit. The tool with the most completed gifts and the cleanest statement wins, and the best donor management software for churches should prove that match before any church pays.

How to Choose the Best Donor Management Software For Churches

Start with the giving volume the church already receives, because that decides the shortlist before price does. Add up last year online gifts, multiply by the card rate of each tool and compare the totals, since a 0.75 percent rate difference on 500,000 dollars is 3,750 dollars a year. A church with modest volume should weigh the monthly fee more, while a church with high volume should weigh the card rate more.

Next, check the statement. A church must produce annual, quarterly or custom period statements that donors can print or receive by email, with fund tracking that matches the accounting system. Test the statement with real gift data before paying, because a statement that needs manual fixing at tax time is a failure no matter how pretty the dashboard is.

Then look at the fund accounting, since this is where churches differ from charities. A church that tracks building funds, missions funds and general funds separately needs fund accounting in the tool or a clean export to the ledger, and the best donor management software for churches should handle funds without a workaround.

The 15 Tools in Detail

The order below follows the church workflow, so the giving leader opens the list and the forms specialist closes it. Each entry states the price as published or reported, the fee that matters and the job it fits, because the best donor management software for churches earns its place on the statements it produces.

1. Tithe.ly

Tithe.ly is the online giving platform for churches that lead with giving. The giving platform has no monthly fee and no setup fee, with card gifts at 2.9 percent plus 30 cents and bank gifts at 1 percent plus 30 cents, and it covers text to give, app giving, kiosk mode and stock gifts. Church Management is reported at 49 dollars a month in some sources and 72 dollars a month in others, with an All Access bundle at 119 dollars a month that adds a branded app, website and worship tools, so confirm the current figure before budgeting.

The drawback is the price spread and the module cost. The giving is free but the management layer is paid, and the conflicting reported prices mean the quote is the only number that counts.

Start with giving only, run it for a month and add Church Management only when the people records prove the need.

2. Planning Center Giving

Planning Center Giving is the giving module inside the Planning Center suite, and its card rate is the lowest in this guide. Card gifts cost 2.15 percent plus 30 cents, bank gifts cost 0 percent plus 30 cents, and the module is free up to 10 donations a month, then 15 to 239 dollars a month by volume. On 500,000 dollars of online giving a year, Planning Center Giving costs about 8,130 to 10,818 dollars, against about 12,200 dollars for Tithe.ly.

The drawback is the modular cost climb. The suite is bought module by module, with Services, Giving, Check Ins, Calendar, Groups and Registrations at roughly 15 dollars each, so a church that adds modules can reach 239 dollars a month for a fuller stack.

Price the full module stack the church needs, not just Giving, and compare the total with Tithe.ly before deciding.

3. Pushpay

Pushpay is the unified platform for growing and multisite churches that want giving, church management and a mobile app from one vendor. ChurchStaq brings those pieces together, with giving, the MyChurch app, Spanish language giving and stock gifts, and the platform covers donor reporting and receipts across annual, quarterly or custom periods. Pricing is quote based, with reported figures from 200 dollars a month upward depending on size.

The drawback is the quote only price and the enterprise focus. A small church cannot budget Pushpay from the website, and the platform is built for larger congregations, so a church of eighty will pay for scale it never uses.

Ask Pushpay for a written quote at the real attendance and campus count, and compare the total with the Planning Center stack.

4. Breeze

Breeze is the simple flat rate church management tool for small churches that want one database any volunteer can learn in an afternoon. The price is 72 dollars a month flat, with unlimited members, no contract and no setup fee, and the team will migrate existing data free. Breeze is now owned by Tithe.ly and has been rebranded as Tithely Church Management, so buyers should read it as a Tithe.ly product.

The drawback is the light accounting and reporting. Breeze offers no fund accounting depth, and the standalone management tools run under 70 dollars a month in some reports, so the exact figure should be confirmed.

Trial Breeze with the real member list, check that a volunteer can find a giver in under a minute and confirm the statement output before paying.

5. ChurchTrac

ChurchTrac is the all in one church management tool with fund accounting included in every plan. Prices run from 29 dollars to 119 dollars a month by the number of names tracked, with accounting and messaging as add ons, and the platform covers contributions, statements, attendance and communication in one bill. That accounting inclusion is rare at this price, and it is why small churches pick ChurchTrac over a giving only tool.

The drawback is the add on creep. Accounting costs extra at 15 dollars a month and messaging at 7 dollars, so the true bill is higher than the entry price, and the interface is more functional than beautiful.

Count the names the church tracks, add the accounting and messaging add ons and compare the true total with Breeze before deciding.

6. Realm

Realm is the church management platform by ACS Technologies for churches that want a full suite from an established vendor. It covers people, groups, giving, accounting and communication, with a mobile app and a history in church software that predates most tools in this guide. Pricing is quote based, so the church must ask for a number based on size and modules.

The drawback is the quote only price and the setup weight. A small church cannot budget Realm from the website, and the full suite takes longer to implement than Breeze or ChurchTrac.

Ask ACS for a written quote that includes every module the church needs, and trial the giving and statement workflow with real data.

7. Aplos

Aplos is the fund accounting platform for churches that need deep accounting beside donor management. Plans run from 79 dollars to 229 dollars a month, with custom pricing above that, and fund accounting sits in every plan, with monthly, quarterly or annual statements and a donor portal. A church that tracks many funds will value the accounting depth more than any other feature in this guide.

The drawback is the price floor and the accounting focus. Seventy nine dollars a month is a lot for a church that only needs giving records, and the giving experience is less polished than Tithe.ly.

Trial Aplos with the real fund structure, run one month of gifts through it and check that the fund balances match the bank.

8. DonorPerfect

DonorPerfect is the donor management and fundraising platform for churches that run campaigns and appeals. It covers donor records, gift tracking, campaigns, acknowledgements and reporting, with a long history in nonprofit fundraising. Pricing is quote based, so the church must ask for a number based on donor count and features.

The drawback is the quote only price and the fundraising focus. A church that does not run campaigns will pay for features it never uses, and the church specific tools are thinner than a platform built for congregations.

Ask DonorPerfect for a quote at the real donor count, and check whether the campaign reporting justifies the price against Tithe.ly.

9. Bloomerang

Bloomerang is the donor retention platform for churches that want to keep givers giving. It tracks donor engagement, flags lapsed givers and helps the church thank donors promptly, with a focus on retention rather than acquisition. Pricing is quote based, and the platform now includes Kindful, which merged into Bloomerang.

The drawback is the quote only price and the retention focus. A church that only needs gift records and statements will find Bloomerang more than it needs, and the church management features are thinner than a full ChMS.

Trial Bloomerang with the real donor list, check how many lapsed givers it flags and decide whether that insight is worth the quote.

10. Little Green Light

Little Green Light is the simple donor database for small churches that want a clean donor record without complexity. The price is reported from 45 dollars a month, with gift tracking, donor profiles, acknowledgements and reporting in a friendly interface. A small church can keep every giver, every gift and every note in one place without learning a large system.

The drawback is the reported price and the narrow scope. Little Green Light covers donor records well but offers no church management, no app and no giving processing of its own, so a church must pair it with a giving tool. The 45 dollar figure is also reported rather than published, so the live pricing page is the authority.

Trial it with the real donor list, enter a month of gifts and check that the year end statement matches the bank.

11. Givelify

Givelify is the mobile first giving app for churches whose givers prefer a phone. The app is free for the church, with gifts processing at 2.9 percent plus 30 cents, and donors can give in a few taps without creating an account. That low friction is why churches with a younger congregation pick Givelify, since the giving happens on the phone in the pew.

The drawback is the narrow scope and the fee. Givelify handles giving well but offers no church management, no statements beyond the basics and no fund accounting, so a church must pair it with a management tool. The 2.9 percent card rate is also higher than Planning Center Giving at 2.15 percent, which matters at high volume.

Run Givelify for a month beside the current giving method, count the mobile gifts and compare the total with the previous month.

12. Subsplash Giving

Subsplash Giving is the giving module inside the Subsplash platform, which covers a church app, media, websites and giving together. The bundled price is reported from 80 dollars a month, with higher tiers to 400 dollars, and the platform suits a church that wants its app, sermons and giving in one place. A church that already streams sermons on Subsplash gets giving that matches the rest of the experience.

The drawback is the bundled price and the reported figure. A church that only needs giving will pay for media and app features it does not use, and the 80 dollar figure is reported rather than published, so the quote is the number that counts. The giving is also less standalone than Tithe.ly.

Ask Subsplash for a bundle quote at the real attendance, and trial the giving flow inside the app before committing.

13. EasyTithe

EasyTithe is the online and text giving tool for churches that want simple text to give. Donors text an amount to a number, the gift processes and the church records it, with online forms beside the text flow. Pricing is quote based, so the church must ask for a number based on volume and features.

The drawback is the quote only price and the narrow scope. EasyTithe handles giving well but offers no church management or fund accounting, so a church must pair it with a management tool. The brand is also smaller than Tithe.ly or Pushpay, so support and integrations are thinner.

Trial EasyTithe with a Sunday announcement, count the text gifts that week and compare the total with the usual offering.

14. ShelbyNext

ShelbyNext is the church management platform with giving for churches that want a full suite from Shelby Systems. It covers people, groups, giving, accounting and communication, with a history in church software that spans decades. Pricing is quote based, so the church must ask for a number based on size and modules.

The drawback is the quote only price and the setup weight. A small church cannot budget ShelbyNext from the website, and the full suite takes longer to implement than Breeze or ChurchTrac. A church that only needs giving will find ShelbyNext far more than it needs.

Ask Shelby for a written quote that includes every module the church needs, and trial the statement workflow with real gift data.

15. DonorSnap

DonorSnap is the donor management tool with online forms for small nonprofits and churches that want flexible data collection. Donor records, gift tracking, online donation forms and reporting come standard, with the price reported from 39 dollars a month. A church that needs custom forms beside its donor records will find DonorSnap flexible where a giving only tool is rigid.

The drawback is the reported price and the narrow church focus. DonorSnap is built for nonprofits broadly, so some church specific workflows need adaptation, and the 39 dollar figure is reported rather than published. The giving processing also needs a separate gateway, so the church must budget that cost too.

Trial DonorSnap with the real donor list, build the pledge form the church actually uses and check that the gift record matches the bank.

Tithe.ly vs Planning Center Giving: Free Start Against Low Fees

Tithe.ly wins on the free start. Giving costs nothing per month, the setup takes days and the feature set covers text, app, kiosk and stock gifts, which is why most churches of two hundred or more pick it first. The trade is the card rate, since 2.9 percent plus 30 cents costs more at high volume than Planning Center Giving at 2.15 percent.

Planning Center Giving wins on the card rate. On 500,000 dollars of online giving a year it costs about 8,130 to 10,818 dollars against about 12,200 dollars for Tithe.ly, which is a saving worth thousands. The trade is the modular cost, since the full Planning Center stack can reach 239 dollars a month, and a church that does not already use Planning Center must learn a new system.

Pick Tithe.ly when the church wants to start free and values giving polish, and pick Planning Center Giving when the church already runs Planning Center or gives at high volume. A church that gives 100,000 dollars a year online will barely notice the rate difference, while a church that gives 500,000 dollars will save enough to matter, which is why the best donor management software for churches is priced on volume first.

small church team in a huddle around a table with no screens and no readable text

What does donor management cost a church per year?

A church should budget by giving volume rather than by headline price. Tithe.ly giving at no monthly fee costs about 14,800 dollars a year in card fees on 500,000 dollars of card gifts at 2.9 percent plus 30 cents, while Planning Center Giving at 2.15 percent costs about 10,750 dollars on the same volume before its monthly module fees. Those figures look far apart, but the value differs, since Tithe.ly includes a polished giving experience and Planning Center Giving includes a lower rate.

The second cost is the monthly subscription. Breeze at 72 dollars a month costs 864 dollars a year, ChurchTrac from 29 dollars a month costs from 348 dollars a year and Aplos from 79 dollars a month costs from 948 dollars a year, all before card fees.

Budget for the card fees first, then the subscription, and ask each vendor for a written quote at the real giving volume before comparing. A tool that looks free can be the most expensive at high volume, and a tool that looks pricey can be the cheapest when the card rate is low.

Can a small church manage donors without a paid tool?

A small church can manage donors without a paid tool when the congregation is small and the giving is simple. A spreadsheet plus Tithe.ly free giving covers gift records, and year end statements can be produced from the giving platform, so a church with fifty givers may never need to pay. A church that records every gift carefully and reconciles monthly will serve its donors well at zero cost.

The ceiling arrives with funds, campuses and volunteers. A church that tracks several funds, runs multiple campuses or hands records to a new volunteer each year needs a real system, because a spreadsheet breaks when the person who built it leaves.

The smart path is to run the free setup for a season, measure whether the statements match the bank and pay only when a limit is hit. A church that pays from day one for capacity it does not use wastes money, while a church that stays on a spreadsheet past the limit risks errors at tax time, and the statement accuracy is the number that tells the treasurer which side of that line the church stands on.

The First Giving Season Checklist

Rolling out donor software works best as a single giving season rather than a big launch. Week one belongs to the gift record, so import the donor list, check that every giver has one record and confirm the fund list matches the accounting system. Week two belongs to the giving flow, so test the online form, the text flow and the app with real gifts of one dollar that are refunded after.

Week three belongs to the statement, so run a test statement for the last quarter and compare it line by line with the bank deposits. Week four belongs to the team, so train the volunteers who record gifts, agree who answers donor questions and set a monthly reconciliation date. A church that follows that sequence will enter the giving season with confidence, while a church that launches without a test statement will discover errors at tax time.

Keep the checklist to one season and one metric, which is statement accuracy against the bank. A church that measures that number will know within a month whether the tool earns its keep, and the reconciled statement is the proof that decides whether the best donor management software for churches stays or goes.

step flow diagram showing the four week donor software rollout from gift record to team training

Frequently Asked Questions

Which donor software is best for a small church?

Tithe.ly is the best pick for a small church, because online giving costs nothing per month and card gifts process at 2.9 percent plus 30 cents, with text to give and app giving included. ChurchTrac from 29 dollars a month is the second pick for a church that wants fund accounting included in one bill.

How much does Tithe.ly cost?

Tithe.ly giving costs nothing per month, with card gifts at 2.9 percent plus 30 cents and bank gifts at 1 percent plus 30 cents, and no setup fee or contract. Church Management is reported at 49 dollars a month in some sources and 72 dollars a month in others, with an All Access bundle at 119 dollars a month, so confirm the current figure before budgeting.

What is the cheapest way for a church to take online gifts?

Tithe.ly and Givelify both offer giving with no monthly fee, with card gifts at 2.9 percent plus 30 cents, while Planning Center Giving is free up to 10 donations a month and then charges 2.15 percent plus 30 cents per card gift. A church with high online volume saves thousands a year on the lower Planning Center Giving rate, and that saving is the reason the best donor management software for churches is compared on card fees first.

Does Breeze still exist?

Breeze still exists as a church management tool at 72 dollars a month flat, but it is now owned by Tithe.ly and has been rebranded as Tithely Church Management. Buyers should read it as a Tithe.ly product, with the same flat rate, unlimited members and free data migration.

Can a church use Planning Center Giving without other Planning Center modules?

Planning Center Giving can be used on its own, with the module free up to 10 donations a month and then priced from 15 dollars a month by volume. A church that only needs giving can buy Giving alone, while a church that wants the full suite adds Services, Check Ins, Groups and the other modules at roughly 15 dollars each.

Do these tools produce year end giving statements?

Tithe.ly, Planning Center Giving, Pushpay, Breeze, ChurchTrac and Aplos all produce year end giving statements, with annual, quarterly or custom periods and email or print delivery. A church should test the statement with real gift data before paying, because a statement that needs manual fixing at tax time is a failure no matter how pretty the dashboard is.

The Final Word for Churches That Give With Care

Tithe.ly takes the top spot for most churches because giving costs nothing per month to start, with text, app and kiosk giving at 2.9 percent plus 30 cents per card gift.

Planning Center Giving is the pick for low fees, Breeze is the pick for simplicity and Aplos is the pick for fund accounting. The best donor management software for churches is not the set with the most features, it is the set that records every gift faithfully and produces a statement every donor can trust.

Choose by the giving volume first, test the statement with real data and count the total annual cost before paying. A church that picks this way will spend less time fixing records and more time serving the people whose gifts it records.

Leave a Comment