Software

Best Church Giving Software (12 Tools)

20 min read

A congregation of 80, a church of 400 with a building fund, and a multi-service church with givers online and in the pews all need to take gifts, and yet the right tool for one of them is often the wrong tool for the other two. This guide to the best church giving software starts with the church, not the software, because the size of the congregation and the way people give decide the tool. Find the church that looks like yours, then read the tools that fit it.

The Small Congregation of 80

Grace Chapel’s treasurer is a volunteer, and that fact shapes every decision. The tool has to be live in a day, the donor flow short enough for a first-time giver to finish without help, and the monthly bill zero, because a $50 fee on $4,000 of gifts is money the church would rather spend on the food bank. The congregation gives in small amounts, often $20 or $25, so the fee on a small gift matters more than any feature list.

Her shortlist from the best church giving software is short on purpose. Tithe.ly Giving costs nothing a month, with card gifts at 2.9% plus 30 cents and bank gifts at 1% plus 30 cents, so the church can take its first online gift today. Givelify is just as free, with a flat 2.9% plus 30 cents per card gift, and donors give in three taps from the app, which is the smoothest flow in this guide. ChurchTrac is third, because the free tier covers the basics and paid plans are reported from $6 a month, which makes it the cheapest paid start here.

The deal-breaker for Grace Chapel is the fee on a $25 gift. On Tithe.ly by card that gift costs $1.03 in fees, so the church keeps $23.97, while by bank it costs 55 cents, so the church keeps $24.45. That 48-cent difference looks small once, and it is $48 a month across 100 gifts, which is a real number for a small church. Her second deal-breaker is a sales call. A tool that publishes no price cannot be budgeted by a volunteer treasurer.

What would I do if I were that treasurer? I would start on Tithe.ly, turn on the donor-covers-the-fee option, and ask the congregation to give by bank where they can. That one ask saves more money than any platform switch ever will.

close-up of a paper offering envelope beside a hymn book on a wooden pew (2048x1152, 16:9)

Three Churches, Three Different Giving Needs

Meet the three churches this guide is written for. Grace Chapel has 80 members, one Sunday service and a volunteer treasurer who does the books on a Tuesday night, and it takes about $4,000 a month in gifts. Riverside Church has 400 members, a building fund for a new roof, and a part-time administrator. City Church runs three services a weekend, streams one of them, and takes gifts online, by text and in the pews.

Buy the wrong one and each church regrets it differently, so this guide to the best church giving software gives each church its own shortlist, and the full tool run later is grouped the same way.

ToolMonthly feeCard rate
Tithe.lyFree2.9% plus 30 cents
PushpayQuote onlyReported 2.1 to 2.9%
Planning Center GivingFree to $2392.15% plus 30 cents
Subsplash GivingNo fee for givingFrom 2.99% plus 30 cents
GivelifyFree2.9% plus 30 cents
EasyTitheQuote onlyQuote only
BreezeFrom $50Card rate on top
ChurchTracFree tier, from $6Card rate on top
DonorboxFree start1.5% platform plus card
SecureGive$149 to $299Card rate on top
VancoQuote onlyQuote only
RebelGiveQuote onlyQuote only

Tithe.ly vs Givelify: Free Giving Against Free Giving

Tithe.ly and Givelify both cost nothing a month, and both charge 2.9% plus 30 cents on a card gift, so the difference is not the price. It is what sits behind the gift. Tithe.ly is a church platform that starts with free giving and grows into church management, a custom app, a website and worship tools for $119 a month on the All Access plan. Givelify is a giving app and nothing else, and it does that one job beautifully, with a 4.9-star app and money arriving the next business day.

The trade-off is simple. Givelify is cheaper in effort and narrower in scope, but you lose the road ahead, because when the church wants an app or a member database, there is nowhere to grow. If the church only ever wants giving, Givelify is the honest pick. If the church might want more in two years, Tithe.ly is the better buy.

The Church With a Building Fund

Riverside Church is raising money for a new roof, and that changes the job completely. The church does not just need a giving button. It needs a gift for the roof to land in the roof fund, a gift for the mission trip to land in the mission fund, and a report that shows the treasurer exactly which is which. A tool that dumps every gift into one pot will cost the administrator hours every month.

Its shortlist starts with Planning Center Giving, because the bank gift rate is a flat 30 cents with no percentage, which is the cheapest way to take a large gift in this guide. Tithe.ly is second, because the fund designations are clear and the donor can pick a fund on the giving page itself. Donorbox is third, because its forms embed on the website in minutes and handle recurring gifts, which suits a building campaign that runs for a year.

The deal-breaker for Riverside is the fund designation on the donor’s screen. If the giver cannot see “Roof Fund” as a choice before they pay, the gift will land in the general fund and the administrator will spend Monday fixing it. The second deal-breaker is the fee on a large gift. A $250 gift by card on Tithe.ly costs $7.55, so the church keeps $242.45, while by bank it costs $2.80, so the church keeps $247.20. Across a campaign of 200 such gifts, the bank route saves nearly $1,000.

Worked example, from the prices in this guide. Riverside takes $10,000 a month, mostly in $25 gifts, which is 400 gifts. On Tithe.ly by card, 400 gifts at $1.03 each cost $412 a month in fees. On Planning Center by bank, 400 gifts at 30 cents each cost $120 a month. The gap is $292 a month, which is $3,504 a year. The catch is that members have to choose bank giving, and that takes a Sunday announcement and a patient explanation.

flow diagram showing a gift moving from donor to roof fund to receipt with three labelled steps (2048x1152, 16:9)

The Multi-Service Church

City Church has three services, a streamed service, a lobby kiosk, and givers who span three generations. The youngest give from a phone during the sermon. The oldest give in the pew. The administrator needs one report on Monday morning that shows all of it, by service, by fund, by method, without merging three spreadsheets.

Its shortlist from the best church giving software starts with Pushpay, because it serves more than 14,000 churches, including seven of the ten largest congregations in the United States, and it has processed more than $62 billion in gifts. Subsplash is second, because the church app, the website, the media library and the giving sit in one platform, and text giving is included free, which is more generous than Tithe.ly at $19 a month. SecureGive is third, because it publishes its price at $149 to $299 a month, covers kiosks, a mobile app and multi-campus reporting, and suits a lobby where people give on their way out.

The deal-breaker for City Church is text giving that actually works for older members. A text flow that needs an app download will lose the very people who give most faithfully, while a flow that works from a plain text message will reach them. The second deal-breaker is the Monday report. If the giving data does not flow into the member records automatically, the administrator will spend the morning retyping gifts.

Best Pick by Job

ChurchFirst pickSecond toolWhy this pair works
Small congregation of 80Tithe.lyGivelifyBoth are free and live in a day
Church with a building fundPlanning Center GivingTithe.lyBoth handle funds and cheap bank gifts
Multi-service churchPushpaySubsplashBoth cover app, text and in-person giving

If you are Grace Chapel, start on Tithe.ly and ask the congregation to give by bank. If you are Riverside, build the campaign on Planning Center Giving and check the fund report every Monday. If you are City Church, get quotes from Pushpay and Subsplash, and test the text flow on the oldest phone in the building before you sign. The table above is the short version of the best church giving software, and the detail run below is the long version, grouped by the same three churches.

How Much Does a $25 Gift Really Cost a Church?

Take a $25 gift, because that is the gift a small church sees most. On Tithe.ly by card it costs 2.9%, which is 73 cents, plus 30 cents, which is $1.03, so the church keeps $23.97. On Tithe.ly by bank it costs 1%, which is 25 cents, plus 30 cents, which is 55 cents, so the church keeps $24.45. On Planning Center by bank it costs a flat 30 cents, so the church keeps $24.70, and on Planning Center by card it costs 2.15%, which is 54 cents, plus 30 cents, which is 84 cents, so the church keeps $24.16.

The pattern is clear. The card is convenient and the bank is cheap, and the gap between them is the price of convenience. A church that moves half its givers to bank giving keeps hundreds of dollars a month. Donorbox adds a wrinkle, with a 1.5% platform fee on top of the card rate, so the same $25 gift costs about $1.40 there, and the church keeps $23.60.

Can a Church Take Online Gifts Without a Monthly Fee?

Yes, and most small churches should. Tithe.ly Giving, Givelify, Subsplash Giving and Donorbox all start free, with no monthly fee and no setup fee, and the church pays only the processing cost on each gift. RebelGive also aims at no monthly fee, though it publishes no price, so a church should confirm that on a call. The free tools are not trials. They are the real product, funded by the processing fees and, on some platforms, by optional donor tips.

The catch is what the free tier leaves out. Text giving costs $19 a month on Tithe.ly and on Donorbox, while Subsplash includes it free. The church app, the website and the management system sit behind the $119 a month All Access plan on Tithe.ly. A church should start free and only pay when it knows which paid feature it is buying.

Is Text Giving Worth It for an Older Congregation?

Text giving is worth it only if the oldest givers can use it without help, and that is a test, not an assumption. A flow that asks a 78-year-old to download an app, create an account and verify an email will lose that giver, however good the tool is. A flow that works from a plain text message, with a short number and a clear reply, will reach them. Test it on the oldest phone in the building, with the person who owns that phone doing the tapping.

The cost side is straightforward, and it is the kind of detail the best church giving software guides usually skip. Tithe.ly charges $19 a month for text giving on its own, and Subsplash includes it free with Subsplash Giving, so the price difference is $228 a year. That is worth paying if the text gifts it brings in exceed it, and most churches find they do, because a giver who can give in ten seconds during the sermon gives more often.

How to Choose the Best Church Giving Software

Start with the gift, not the feature list. How big are the gifts, how often do they come, and do the givers use cards, bank transfers or text? A church of 80 with $25 gifts needs a low fee on small gifts and no monthly charge. A church with a building fund needs fund designations and cheap bank gifts for large amounts. A multi-service church needs text, app and kiosk giving in one report. The tool that fits the gift will still fit in a year.

Next, test the donor flow yourself, on a phone, in the pew. Give one dollar, check that the receipt arrives, and confirm the fund is correct. A giving page that works on the oldest phone will work for everyone. Finally, check the recurring gift setup, because recurring giving is the most stable income a church has, and a donor should be able to change or cancel it without calling the office.

The 12 Tools in Detail

The twelve tools below, the full best church giving software list, are grouped by the church they fit best, in the same order as the churches above. Read your group first, then skim the rest.

For the small congregation: Tithe.ly, Givelify, ChurchTrac and RebelGive.

1. Tithe.ly

Tithe.ly is the online giving platform for small to mid-size churches, and it is the most popular free start in this guide. The Giving plan costs nothing a month, with card gifts at 2.9% plus 30 cents, bank gifts at 1% plus 30 cents, and American Express at 3.5% plus 30 cents. Text giving costs $19 a month on its own, or comes with the All Access plan at $119 a month.

The free start is the core strength. A church can take its first online gift today with no setup fee, no monthly fee and no contract, and the donor can cover the fee, so the church keeps the full gift. The All Access plan adds church management, a custom app, a website and worship tools for a flat $119 a month.

Worked example, from the prices in this guide. A church taking $4,000 a month in 160 gifts of $25 pays about $165 a month in card fees on Tithe.ly, or about $88 a month if every gift comes by bank. The $77 gap is worth one Sunday announcement.

The limit is the bundle creep. The free tier covers giving only, so a church that wants the app, the website and the management system pays $119 a month for modules it may not use.

Tithe.ly suits a small church that wants to start free and grow into a platform later. It is the first pick for Grace Chapel.

2. Pushpay

Pushpay is the full church platform for large and multi-site churches, and it is the biggest name in this guide. It covers giving with Everygift, a church management system, kids check-in, a mobile app and pre-launch onboarding for new churches. Pushpay quotes the platform price and publishes no monthly fee, while the card rate is reported at 2.1 to 2.9% plus 20 to 30 cents depending on giving volume.

The scale is the core strength. Pushpay serves more than 14,000 churches, including seven of the ten largest congregations in the United States, and it has processed more than $62 billion in gifts. A large church gets dedicated support and donor retention tools that a small platform cannot match.

The limit is the price opacity. Pushpay publishes no pricing at all, so a church cannot budget without a sales call, and industry reports put giving-only pricing near $199 to $400 a month.

3. Planning Center Giving

Planning Center Giving is the low-fee giving tool for churches that watch every dollar, and it has the lowest published card rate in this guide. The plan is free up to ten donations a month, then priced by monthly donation count from $15 to $239 a month. Card gifts cost 2.15% plus 30 cents, and bank gifts cost a flat 30 cents with no percentage.

The bank gift rate is the core strength. A $100 bank gift costs 30 cents on Planning Center, against $1.30 on Tithe.ly and $3.20 by card almost everywhere else. A church that moves its members to bank giving saves hundreds of dollars a month.

Worked example, from the prices in this guide. A $100 gift by bank costs 30 cents here, against $3.20 by card on Tithe.ly. Across 100 gifts a month, the bank route saves $290. The maths only works if members actually choose bank giving, so the announcement matters more than the plan.

The limit is the modular pricing. Planning Center charges per module, so a church that wants the full suite pays for each piece separately, and the total adds up.

Planning Center Giving suits a church with a building fund, a treasurer who counts pennies, and members willing to give by bank. It is the first pick for Riverside Church, and the cheapest way to take a large gift in this guide.

4. Subsplash Giving

Subsplash Giving is the giving tool for churches building a digital presence, and it is the pick for a church that wants an app, a website and giving in one system. Giving itself has no monthly subscription fee, with card processing from 2.99% plus 30 cents for giving-only customers, dropping to 2.3% plus 30 cents under the Exclusive Partnership tier, and bank gifts at 1%.

The app depth is the core strength. Subsplash builds the church app, the website, the media library and the giving into one platform, so a member watches the sermon, gives and signs up for an event without leaving the app. Text giving is included free, which is more generous than Tithe.ly at $19 a month.

The limit is the rate spread. The 2.3% rate needs the Exclusive Partnership tier, and the standard 2.99% rate is the highest in this guide.

For the mid-size church: Planning Center Giving, Subsplash Giving, Breeze and Donorbox.

5. Givelify

Givelify is the mobile giving app for churches that want zero commitment, and it is the simplest start in this guide. It charges no monthly fee, no setup fee and no contract, with a flat 2.9% plus 30 cents per card gift and 3.5% plus 30 cents on American Express. Donors download the app, search for the church and give in three taps.

The zero commitment is the core strength. A church can be live today with no contract and no monthly bill, and the money arrives the next business day. The app is rated 4.9 stars, and the donor experience is the smoothest in this guide. The limit is the narrow scope. Givelify is a giving app, not a church platform, so there is no church management, no website and no text giving in the true SMS sense.

6. EasyTithe

EasyTithe is the online giving tool for small churches that want a simple setup, and it is one of the oldest names in church giving. It covers online giving, text giving, recurring gifts, a mobile app and reporting, with a focus on getting a small church live fast. No price is published, so a church learns the cost on a sales call.

The simplicity is the core strength. EasyTithe sets up in a day, the donor flow is short and clear, and the reporting shows the church where every gift came from without a finance degree. The limit is the price opacity and the narrow scope. EasyTithe publishes no price, and it does not offer the management tools that Tithe.ly or Breeze bundle.

7. Breeze

Breeze is the church management system with giving built in, and it is the pick for a small church that wants one system for everything. The platform is reported from $50 a month, and it covers giving, member management, contributions, events, volunteers and reporting in a single system that a volunteer can learn in an afternoon.

What Breeze does well for a small church:

  • Giving flows straight into the contribution records, so the treasurer never exports a file or retypes a gift.
  • The interface is clean enough for a volunteer with no IT background.
  • Events, volunteers and reporting sit in the same dashboard as the giving.

The limit is the scale. Breeze is built for small churches, and a large or multi-site church will outgrow it.

8. ChurchTrac

ChurchTrac is the church management system with giving built in, and it is the pick for a small church on a tight budget. The free tier covers the basics, and paid plans are reported from $6 a month, which makes it the cheapest paid start in this guide. It covers giving, member management, contributions, events and reporting.

Is ChurchTrac enough for a church of 80? Yes, if the treasurer is patient and the church does not need a polished app. The price is the core strength, since a church can run its whole management system for a few dollars a month, and the free tier lets a church plant start with no budget at all. The giving tools cover online gifts, recurring gifts and contribution statements, which is everything a small church needs. The limit is the polish. ChurchTrac is simpler and less polished than Breeze or Tithe.ly, and the integrations are thinner, so a church that wants a beautiful member experience should look elsewhere.

9. Donorbox

Donorbox is the donation form platform for churches that want simple forms fast, and it is the pick for a church that needs a form on the website today. It is free to start, with a 1.5% platform fee plus standard card processing at 2.9% plus 30 cents, and the forms embed on any website in minutes. The form speed is the core strength. A church builds a donation form, embeds it on the website, and takes gifts the same day, with recurring options, donor covers the fee, and text giving at $19 a month. The platform also covers peer-to-peer fundraising and events, which suits a church running a building campaign.

The limit is the church depth. Donorbox is a donation platform, not a church platform, so there is no member management, no kids check-in and no church app.

10. SecureGive

SecureGive is the giving platform for large and multi-campus churches, and it is the pick for a church that wants a published price at scale. Plans run from $149 to $299 a month plus add-ons, and the platform covers online giving, text giving, kiosks, a mobile app and multi-campus reporting.

The published price is the core strength. SecureGive is one of the few large church platforms that publishes its price, so a church can budget before the sales call. The kiosk giving suits a large lobby, the multi-campus reporting suits a church with several sites, and the dedicated support suits a team that needs help on a Sunday morning. The limit is the entry price. SecureGive starts at $149 a month, which is more than a small church should pay for giving alone.

11. Vanco

Vanco is the giving and payments platform for churches with many payment types, and it is the pick for a church that takes gifts, event fees, school tuition and facility rentals through one system. It covers online giving, text giving, mobile giving, event payments and reporting. Vanco hands each church a quote.

The payment breadth is the core strength. Vanco handles the church giving, the school payments and the event fees in one platform, so a church with a school or a busy events calendar does not need three vendors. The platform has served churches for decades, and the support team knows the church calendar. The limit is the price opacity. Vanco publishes no price, so a church cannot budget without a sales call.

12. RebelGive

RebelGive is the simple online giving tool for churches that want no monthly fee and no complexity, and it is the quietest pick in this guide. It covers online giving, recurring gifts and a simple donor flow, with a focus on getting a church live fast. Pricing is on request, with no published monthly fee.

The simplicity is the core strength. RebelGive does one job, taking online gifts, and it does it without a platform decision, a contract or a long setup. A church that wants giving and nothing else will be live in a day, and the donor flow is short enough that a first-time giver finishes it without help. The limit is the narrow scope and the price opacity. RebelGive is giving only, with no management tools and no published price.

Frequently Asked Questions

How much does Tithe.ly cost per month?

Tithe.ly Giving costs nothing a month, with card gifts at 2.9% plus 30 cents and bank gifts at 1% plus 30 cents. Text giving costs $19 a month on its own, and the All Access plan costs $119 a month.

What is the cheapest church giving software?

ChurchTrac is the cheapest paid start, with a free tier and paid plans reported from $6 a month. Tithe.ly and Givelify are free to start. Planning Center Giving is the cheapest per gift for bank giving, at a flat 30 cents.

Does Pushpay publish its pricing?

No. Pushpay quotes the platform price and publishes no monthly fee. Industry reports put giving-only pricing near $199 to $400 a month, and the card rate is reported at 2.1 to 2.9% plus 20 to 30 cents.

Can donors cover the processing fee?

Yes, on Tithe.ly, Donorbox and most tools in this guide. The donor ticks a box and the fee is added to the gift, so the church keeps the full amount.

Is text giving worth the extra cost?

Yes, if the congregation uses it. Tithe.ly charges $19 a month for text giving, while Subsplash includes it free. Test the flow on the oldest phone in the building first, because a text flow that needs an app download will lose the older givers who give most faithfully.

How long does it take to set up church giving software?

Tithe.ly, Givelify and Donorbox can be live the same day, with no setup fee and no contract. Pushpay, Subsplash and SecureGive take longer, because the app, the kiosk or the multi-campus setup needs a proper rollout.

Pick Your Church, Then Pick Your Tool

If you are Grace Chapel, start on Tithe.ly and ask the congregation to give by bank. If you are Riverside, build the roof campaign on Planning Center Giving, check the fund report every Monday, and thank every donor by name within a week.

If you are City Church, get quotes from Pushpay and Subsplash, and test the text flow on the oldest phone in the building. That is the whole guide to the best church giving software in three sentences, and the gift maths above is there to check the numbers behind them. Pick your church first, then pick your tool, and give one dollar through your own giving page before you tell the congregation it is live.

Leave a Comment