TransUnion SmartMove is the best tenant screening software for landlords pick for most owners, because the bureau-direct reports cover credit, criminal and eviction history with a ResidentScore, starting at 25 dollars per applicant. RentPrep is the pick when a human review of the report matters, and TurboTenant is the pick when the landlord wants the applicant to pay. The fifteen tools below compare price per report, report depth and who pays, so a landlord can screen every applicant properly without overpaying.
Tenant screening is the decision that protects the rent. A bad tenant costs months of lost rent, legal fees and repairs, while a good screening report costs 25 to 55 dollars and takes minutes. The landlords who skip screening to save 30 dollars are the ones who pay thousands later.
The buying problem is the price spread and the payer. SmartMove charges 25 to 49 dollars by tier, RentPrep charges 29 to 49 dollars, Avail charges about 55 dollars, TurboTenant charges 45 to 55 dollars to the applicant, and the property management platforms bundle screening into a monthly subscription.
The 15 Tools at a Glance
| Tool | Main job | Best for | Starting price |
|---|---|---|---|
| TransUnion SmartMove | Bureau-direct screening | Most landlords | 25 dollars per report |
| RentPrep | Human-reviewed screening | Accuracy first | 29 dollars per report |
| MyRental | CoreLogic screening with risk score | Risk-model landlords | 35 dollars per report |
| Avail | Screening inside a landlord platform | Small landlords, all-in-one | 55 dollars per report |
| TurboTenant | Screening inside a free platform | Applicant-paid screening | 45 dollars per report |
| RentRedi | Screening inside rent management | RentRedi users | Quote-based |
| Zillow Rental Manager | Screening with listings | Landlords listing on Zillow | Applicant-paid |
| Apartments.com | Screening with listings | Landlords listing widely | Applicant-paid |
| TenantCloud | Screening inside a free platform | Small landlords | Free tier |
| Buildium | Screening inside property management | Growing portfolios | Quote-based |
| AppFolio | Screening inside property management | Large portfolios | Quote-based |
| Rentec Direct | Screening inside property software | Small to mid portfolios | 35 dollars a month |
| Snappt | Fraud detection on documents | High-fraud markets | Quote-based |
| First Advantage | Enterprise background screening | Large operators | Quote-based |
| RentSpree | Screening with applications | Agent-assisted rentals | 39.99 dollars per report |
Best Pick by Job
| Job type | First pick | Second tool | Why this pair works |
|---|---|---|---|
| Single-family landlord | SmartMove | RentPrep | SmartMove is bureau-direct, RentPrep adds human review |
| Landlord wanting applicant to pay | TurboTenant | Avail | TurboTenant is free to the landlord, Avail adds the lease |
| Landlord wanting all-in-one | Avail | TenantCloud | Avail covers the lifecycle, TenantCloud starts free |
| Portfolio of 50 plus units | AppFolio | Buildium | AppFolio scales largest, Buildium suits the mid-size |
| High-fraud rental market | Snappt | SmartMove | Snappt catches fake documents, SmartMove screens the person |
A landlord with five units should start with SmartMove. The three tiers are SmartCheck Basic at 25 dollars with ResidentScore plus a national criminal report, Plus at 40 dollars adding the full credit report and eviction-related report, and Premium at 49 dollars adding Income Insights and an identity check. The landlord or the applicant can pay, the report arrives the same day, and the ResidentScore is the closest thing the rental industry has to a FICO-equivalent for tenancy outcomes.
A landlord who wants screening inside a free platform should start with TurboTenant instead. The core platform, listing marketing, applications, screening and rent collection, is free for landlords, funded by applicant fees of 45 to 55 dollars per screening, reduced to 45 dollars when the landlord carries the top-tier plan. The report covers credit, criminal background and eviction across 50 states and the District of Columbia.
Which Tenant Screening Service Is Best for a Small Landlord?
SmartMove is the best pick for a small landlord, because the bureau-direct report is the most trusted in the industry, the price starts at 25 dollars, and there is no subscription to buy. A landlord with one vacancy can order one report, pay 25 dollars and decide the same day, which is the whole job for a small owner.
RentPrep is the better pick when accuracy matters more than speed. FCRA-certified screeners check background results before delivery, filtering the false matches that automated searches produce, and the Credit Report Only package costs 29 dollars, the Full Background Check Only costs 29 dollars, and the Complete Screening Package costs 49 dollars. The human review takes about an hour during office hours, which is worth it when a false match could reject a good tenant.
MyRental is the third option for a landlord who wants a risk model. The CoreLogic report costs about 35 dollars and adds a SafeRent risk score alongside the credit, criminal and eviction data, which suits a landlord with ten to thirty units who screens on a model rather than a gut feeling. The trade-off is less brand recognition than SmartMove.
How to Choose the Best Tenant Screening Software for Landlords
Start with who pays. SmartMove, RentPrep and RentSpree let the landlord or the applicant pay, TurboTenant and Avail usually pass the fee to the applicant, and the platform tools bundle the cost into a subscription. The best tenant screening software for landlords is the one whose payment model matches the lease, because a landlord who pays for every report on ten applicants a month spends 250 to 550 dollars per vacancy.
Next, check the report depth. A basic credit-only report at 25 to 29 dollars misses the eviction history that matters most, and the full credit, criminal and eviction package at 40 to 55 dollars is the report a landlord should actually buy. Income verification is an add-on on most tools, at about 10 dollars on RentPrep, and it is worth buying when the rent is high.
Then check FCRA compliance. A landlord who rejects an applicant must send an adverse-action notice, and the tool should help with that step. RentSpree automates the adverse-action letter, SmartMove provides a template, and RentPrep supports the process with its certified screeners. Finally, check the state rules, because some states limit what a landlord may charge an applicant or when criminal history may be checked, and New York City restricts criminal-history inquiry until after a conditional offer.

The 15 Tools in Detail
The fifteen tools below cover standalone screening, landlord platforms and property management suites. Each one is judged on price per report, report depth, who pays and FCRA support, so this roundup of the best tenant screening software for landlords stays honest about what each report actually covers.
1. TransUnion SmartMove
TransUnion SmartMove is the direct-from-the-bureau screening option, and it offers three packages. SmartCheck Basic costs 25 dollars with ResidentScore plus a criminal background report, Plus costs 40 dollars and adds the full credit report and eviction-related report, and Premium costs 49 dollars and adds Income Insights and an identity check. The landlord or the applicant can pay, and reports arrive the same day.
The bureau-direct data is the strength. The ResidentScore is built from TransUnion rental data, the credit report comes from the bureau itself, and the eviction coverage is nationwide. A landlord who wants the most trusted report in the industry starts here, and the pay-as-you-go model means no subscription for a landlord with one vacancy a year.
The limit is the adverse-action process, which is manual with a template provided, and the income data only arrives on Premium. It suits most landlords from one unit to fifty. Start on Plus at 40 dollars, because Basic lacks the full credit and eviction reports that make the decision, and move to Premium when income verification matters.
2. RentPrep
RentPrep is the human-reviewed screening service in this guide, and its packages are Credit Report Only at 29 dollars, Full Background Check Only at 29 dollars, and the Complete Screening Package at 49 dollars, with add-ons of 10 dollars for income verification and 15 dollars for income and employment verification through applicant-authorised payroll or bank data. The background-only package is landlord-paid, while the other packages offer payment options.
The human review is the strength. FCRA-certified screeners check background results before delivery, filtering the false matches that automated searches produce, which protects both the landlord and the applicant. The turnaround is about an hour during office hours, which is fast enough for most vacancies.
The drawback is the slower delivery outside office hours and the landlord-paid background-only package. It suits landlords who value accuracy over speed, especially in markets where a false match is common. Order the Complete Package at 49 dollars when the decision is close, and use the credit-only package for a first pass.
3. MyRental
MyRental is the CoreLogic screening service, and the report costs about 35 dollars per applicant. It covers credit, criminal and eviction data, and adds a SafeRent risk score that models the tenancy risk from the combined data. The landlord or the applicant can pay, and the report is built for landlords who screen on a model rather than a single score.
The risk score is the strength. A landlord with ten to thirty units can compare applicants on one number, which speeds the decision and keeps it consistent across vacancies. The CoreLogic data is deep, and the eviction coverage is nationwide.
The limit is brand recognition. Applicants and agents know SmartMove by name, and MyRental is less familiar, which can slow the application step. It suits risk-model landlords with a steady flow of applicants. Use the SafeRent score as a first filter, and read the full report before rejecting anyone.
4. Avail
Avail is the all-in-one landlord platform from Realtor.com, and its screening costs about 55 dollars per applicant. The Unlimited plan is free per unit and includes listing syndication, applications, tenant-initiated TransUnion credit, criminal and eviction reports, state-specific leases with digital signing, rent collection and maintenance tracking. Unlimited Plus at 9 dollars per unit a month adds FastPay, waived ACH fees and lease customisation.
The platform is the strength. A landlord can list, screen, lease, collect rent and track maintenance in one free system, which is more than any standalone screening tool offers. The screening itself is a full TransUnion report, so the quality matches the specialists.
The drawback is the 55 dollar report price, which is the highest in this guide alongside TurboTenant, and the screening fee is separate from the free platform. It suits landlords with one to five units who want the whole lifecycle in one place. Start on the free Unlimited plan, and only pay for Plus when the FastPay and waived fees matter.
5. TurboTenant
TurboTenant is the free landlord platform in this guide, with listing marketing, applications, screening and rent collection free for landlords, funded by applicant fees. Applicants pay 55 dollars for a screening covering credit, criminal background and eviction, reduced to 45 dollars when the landlord carries the top-tier plan, and the landlord can choose to cover the fee itself.
The free platform is the strength. A landlord with one to twenty-five units can run the whole rental workflow without a subscription, and the screening is applicant-paid, so the landlord pays nothing for the report. The denial-letter workflow is pre-built, which helps with FCRA compliance.
The limit is the applicant fee. A 55 dollar fee can deter applicants in a soft market, and the landlord who covers it pays more per report than SmartMove Basic. It suits owner-operators who want a free platform and applicant-paid screening. Use it when the market is strong enough that applicants will pay, and switch to SmartMove when the fee starts losing applicants.
6. RentRedi
RentRedi is a rent management platform with screening inside it, covering listings, applications, screening, rent collection and maintenance in one system. The platform is built for landlords who want the whole workflow, with screening as one step in the application rather than a separate purchase.
The workflow is the strength. An applicant applies, gets screened and signs the lease in one flow, which cuts the admin that eats a landlord’s week. The drawback is that screening is not the core, so the report depth is thinner than SmartMove or RentPrep. It suits landlords already on RentRedi. Ask for the screening fee in writing before ordering, and compare the report against SmartMove Plus.
7. Zillow Rental Manager
Zillow Rental Manager is the screening tool inside Zillow, the largest rental listing site in the United States, and it covers applications, screening, leases and rent collection alongside the listing. The screening report is applicant-paid, with the fee set by Zillow, and the listing reaches the widest audience of any tool in this guide.
The reach is the strength. A landlord who lists on Zillow gets the most applicants, and the screening sits inside the same application flow, so there is no separate step to lose people. The limit is the platform lock-in, and the report fee is set by Zillow rather than chosen by the landlord. It suits landlords who list on Zillow anyway. List the unit, let the applicants apply and screen inside Zillow, and compare the report against SmartMove before deciding.
8. Apartments.com
Apartments.com is a rental listing platform with screening built in, covering applications, screening, leases and rent collection. The screening is applicant-paid in most cases, and the listing reaches a large audience alongside Zillow. The platform is free for landlords, with the applicant paying for the screening report.
The listing reach is the strength. A landlord listing on Apartments.com gets applicants from a major portal, with screening integrated, so the application and the report arrive together. The drawback is the applicant fee, which varies by state, and thinner screening depth than the specialists. It suits landlords who list widely and want screening inside the listing. Confirm the current report fee before ordering, and read the full report before rejecting an applicant.
9. TenantCloud
TenantCloud is a landlord platform with a free tier, covering listings, applications, screening, leases, rent collection and maintenance. The screening is an add-on inside the platform, with the fee charged per report, and the free tier covers the core landlord tools without a subscription.
The free tier is the strength. A small landlord can run the whole rental workflow for nothing, and pay only for the screening reports it orders. The platform is simple, and the learning curve is short.
The limit is screening depth. The report is a standard check, and a landlord who needs human review or a risk score will find more in RentPrep or MyRental. It suits small landlords who want a free platform first. Start free, order one screening report, and compare it against SmartMove before committing the next vacancy to it.
10. Buildium
Buildium is a property management platform for growing portfolios, covering screening, leasing, rent collection, maintenance and accounting in one system. Screening sits inside the application flow, with reports ordered per applicant and priced by the screening provider. Pricing for the platform itself is quote-based, set by unit count.
The portfolio tools are the strength. A landlord with fifty or more units can manage the whole portfolio, from screening to accounting, in one system, with reporting that shows the health of every unit. The screening is integrated, so the application and the report arrive together.
The drawback is price and scope for a small landlord. A landlord with five units will pay for a platform built for fifty, and the screening alone is cheaper from SmartMove. It suits growing portfolios. Ask for a quote tied to the unit count, and confirm the screening report contents before signing.
11. AppFolio
AppFolio is a property management platform for large portfolios, covering screening, leasing, rent collection, maintenance, accounting and owner reporting in one cloud system. Screening is built into the application flow, with reports from the major bureaus, and the platform is priced by unit count on a quote basis.
The scale is the strength. A landlord or property manager with hundreds of units can run the whole operation in AppFolio, with screening, leasing and accounting connected, and owner reports that keep investors informed. The automation handles the routine steps at volume.
The limit is cost and fit for a small landlord. AppFolio is built for large operators, and a small owner will pay enterprise money for depth it never uses. It suits large portfolios and property managers. Ask for a quote tied to the unit count, and compare the total cost against Buildium before deciding.
12. Rentec Direct
Rentec Direct is a property management software platform for small to mid-size portfolios, with screening, leasing, rent collection, maintenance and accounting built in. The platform pricing starts from 35 dollars a month, which is the cheapest published platform start in this guide, and screening is ordered per report inside the application flow.
The price is the strength. A landlord with a small portfolio can run a full property system for 35 dollars a month, which is less than the screening fees alone on some tools. The platform is straightforward, and the support is built for small operators.
The drawback is depth at scale. A large portfolio will find more in AppFolio or Buildium, and the screening report is a standard check rather than a human-reviewed one. It suits small to mid-size portfolios that want a full system at a low price. Try the entry plan for a month, and check that the screening report covers credit, criminal and eviction before relying on it.
13. Snappt
Snappt is a fraud detection tool for rental applications, and it checks the documents an applicant submits, such as pay stubs and bank statements, for signs of forgery. It does not replace a credit and criminal screening, it sits alongside it, catching the fake documents that a standard report cannot see. Pricing is quote-based.
The fraud detection is the strength. In high-fraud markets, fake pay stubs are the most common way a bad tenant passes screening, and Snappt catches them before the lease is signed. The tool integrates with the major property platforms, so the check runs inside the existing application flow.
The limit is scope. Snappt checks documents, not people, so a landlord still needs SmartMove or RentPrep for the credit, criminal and eviction report. It suits landlords in high-fraud markets and large operators. Ask for a quote tied to the application volume, and run it alongside SmartMove, not instead of it.
14. First Advantage
First Advantage is an enterprise background screening company, covering tenant screening alongside employment and other background checks. It serves large operators and property managers with high application volumes, with screening reports that cover credit, criminal, eviction and identity verification at enterprise scale.
The enterprise depth is the strength. A large operator can screen thousands of applicants a year with consistent reports, integrations and compliance support, which a small-landlord tool cannot match at that volume. The compliance team understands FCRA requirements across states.
The drawback is price and fit for a small landlord. First Advantage is built for volume, and a landlord with one vacancy a year will find the sales process heavy and the price high. Pricing is quote-based. It suits large operators and property managers. Ask for a quote tied to the annual application volume, and compare the per-report cost against SmartMove before signing.
15. RentSpree
RentSpree is a screening and application platform for agent-assisted rentals, covering applications, screening, income and reference checks, and lease signing. The Standard screening costs 39.99 dollars, or 20 dollars in New York, and Comprehensive costs 49.99 dollars, with bank-verified income and reference checks in the higher tier. The platform automates the adverse-action letter, which is the FCRA step most tools leave manual.
The agent workflow is the strength. A landlord working with an agent can run the application, screening and lease in one flow, with the agent and the landlord seeing the same report. The automated adverse-action letter generator is the best FCRA support in this guide.
The limit is the agent focus. A landlord renting directly will find less value in the agent tools, and the 39.99 dollar Standard price is higher than SmartMove Basic at 25 dollars. It suits agent-assisted single-family rentals. Use Standard for a first pass, and move to Comprehensive when income verification matters.
SmartMove vs RentPrep: Speed Against Human Review
The first difference is what each tool trusts. SmartMove trusts the bureau data, with a same-day report from TransUnion, ResidentScore and tiers at 25, 40 and 49 dollars. RentPrep trusts a human, with FCRA-certified screeners checking the background results before delivery, at 29 and 49 dollars, with about an hour turnaround in office hours.
The second difference is the adverse-action step. SmartMove provides a template for the landlord to send, while RentPrep supports the process with its certified screeners, and RentSpree automates the letter entirely. A landlord who has never rejected an applicant should weigh that support heavily, because a wrong adverse-action notice creates legal risk.
The deciding factor is the applicant pool. A landlord screening many applicants quickly should take SmartMove. A landlord deciding on one close applicant should take RentPrep, because the human review catches the false match that an automated report misses. That split is the cleanest way to read the best tenant screening software for landlords when the choice narrows to two.
What Does Tenant Screening Cost Per Vacancy?
The cost per vacancy runs from 25 dollars to about 275 dollars, depending on how many applicants are screened. One SmartMove Plus report at 40 dollars costs 40 dollars. Five applicants at 40 dollars each cost 200 dollars. Five applicants on TurboTenant at 55 dollars each cost the applicants 275 dollars, and the landlord nothing. Five applicants on RentPrep Complete at 49 dollars each cost 245 dollars.
The number that matters is cost per bad tenant avoided. A single eviction costs thousands of dollars in lost rent, legal fees and repairs, so a 200 dollar screening bill on five applicants is cheap insurance. Screening every applicant with the full report is the discipline the best tenant screening software for landlords rewards, because the report depth decides whether the tenant pays the rent.
Can a Landlord Screen Tenants for Free?
Yes, when the applicant pays. TurboTenant and Avail pass the screening fee to the applicant, so the landlord pays nothing for the report, and Zillow and Apartments.com work the same way. A landlord with a strong market can screen every applicant for free, because the applicants pay the 45 to 55 dollar fee as part of applying.
The second path is the free platform. TenantCloud offers a free tier, and TurboTenant and Avail offer free landlord platforms, so the software costs nothing and only the report carries a fee. A landlord who uses the free platform and passes the report fee on runs the whole screening workflow for zero dollars.
The third path is the state limit. Some states cap what a landlord may charge an applicant for screening, and New York City restricts criminal-history inquiry until after a conditional offer. A landlord who ignores the state rule risks a fine that dwarfs the screening fee, so the free path still needs a legal check.
A Screening Checklist for Every Vacancy
Step one is the application. Collect the full application, the consent to screen and the fee, before ordering any report, because a report ordered without consent creates FCRA risk. Step two is the full report, credit, criminal and eviction, from SmartMove Plus or RentPrep Complete, not the cheapest tier.
Step three is income verification. Check that the income covers the rent, usually at three times the monthly rent, and verify it with a pay stub or bank data rather than a stated figure. Step four is the reference check, with a call to the previous landlord, because a previous landlord will say what a report cannot.
Step five is the decision and the notice. Approve in writing, or reject with an adverse-action notice that names the report and the bureau, as the FCRA requires. A landlord who follows those five steps on every vacancy screens fairly, screens legally and rarely takes a bad tenant. That checklist is what the tools in this guide are built to support.

Frequently Asked Questions
Which tenant screening service is best for a small landlord?
SmartMove is the best pick for a small landlord, because the bureau-direct report starts at 25 dollars, needs no subscription and arrives the same day. RentPrep is the alternative when a human review matters, at 29 to 49 dollars per report. Both cover credit, criminal and eviction on the full package, and either one is a sound start among the best tenant screening software for landlords.
How much does SmartMove cost per applicant?
SmartMove offers three tiers, Basic at 25 dollars, Plus at 40 dollars and Premium at 49 dollars, plus applicable tax. Basic covers ResidentScore and a criminal report, Plus adds the full credit report and eviction-related report, and Premium adds Income Insights and an identity check. The landlord or the applicant can pay.
Can the applicant pay for the screening report?
Yes, on most tools. TurboTenant charges applicants 45 to 55 dollars, Avail charges about 55 dollars, and SmartMove, RentPrep and RentSpree let the landlord or the applicant pay. Some states cap the fee a landlord may charge, so check the local rule before passing the cost on.
Does RentPrep really use human reviewers?
Yes. FCRA-certified screeners check background results before delivery, filtering the false matches that automated searches produce. The Credit Report Only package costs 29 dollars, the Full Background Check Only costs 29 dollars, and the Complete Screening Package costs 49 dollars, with about an hour turnaround during office hours.
What is the cheapest way to screen a tenant?
The cheapest route for the landlord is TurboTenant or Avail, where the applicant pays 45 to 55 dollars and the landlord pays nothing. The cheapest report the landlord pays for is SmartMove Basic at 25 dollars, though Plus at 40 dollars is the better buy because it adds the full credit and eviction reports.
Do I need to send an adverse-action notice when I reject an applicant?
Yes, under the FCRA, a landlord who rejects an applicant based on a screening report must send an adverse-action notice naming the report and the bureau. RentSpree automates the letter, SmartMove provides a template, and RentPrep supports the process with its certified screeners. A landlord should never reject on a report without sending the notice.
The Landlord Screening Verdict
A landlord with a few units should buy SmartMove Plus at 40 dollars per report, because the bureau-direct credit, criminal and eviction report is the most trusted in the industry. A landlord who wants a human review should buy RentPrep Complete at 49 dollars. A landlord who wants the applicant to pay should use TurboTenant, where the applicant pays 45 to 55 dollars and the platform is free.
A landlord with a large portfolio should buy AppFolio or Buildium, and a landlord in a high-fraud market should add Snappt. Screen every applicant with the full report, send the adverse-action notice when you reject, and let the rent record prove the choice. That is the whole job of the best tenant screening software for landlords, and it costs less than one month of lost rent.