Here is the scorecard for the top 10 hr software for hourly workers, marked on five criteria, with the proof beside every mark. Free start, time-off handling, shift swaps, labour-cost view, and payroll sync are the five tests, and Homebase leads on the first three. My pick is Homebase, because its free plan covers one location with up to 10 employees, and its Essentials plan costs $24 a location a month on annual billing.
Best Pick by Job
The table below matches each job to its pick, and Homebase leads the list for the most common job in this guide.
| Job | Pick | Why |
|---|---|---|
| A single cafe with 12 staff | Homebase | free up to 10, Essentials $24 a location |
| A team with strict break rules | Deputy | break and overtime controls built in |
| A team on the lowest budget | When I Work | $2.50 a user a month, reported |
| A restaurant | 7shifts | built for restaurants, free tier |
| A team that wants a free start | Sling | free up to 30 users |
The Shift Swap at 9 p.m.
The shift swap comes at 9 p.m., and the manager is at home. A worker cannot make the morning shift, another worker offers to cover it, and the manager has to approve it before the night ends. The tool that handles this lets the swap happen in the app, notifies the manager, and updates the rota before anyone sleeps. The tool that fails leaves the swap in a group chat, and the morning shift starts with nobody there.
Homebase and Deputy both handle this well, with swap requests that need approval and notifications that reach the manager. The tools that fail are the ones that let workers swap without approval, because the manager finds out at 7 a.m. that the wrong person is on shift. A swap without approval is a rota that nobody owns.
Here is the worked example. A team of 12 at $15 an hour costs $180 an hour, and a missed shift that leaves the team short for two hours costs $360 in lost cover, plus the overtime for the worker who stays late. A tool that approves the swap at 9 p.m. saves the morning, and a tool that misses it costs the morning. The swap is not a message, it is a shift..
Anyone weighing top 10 hr software for hourly workers should test Homebase on the exact job above, because the test shows the difference faster than any feature list.

The 8 Tools at a Glance
The table below is the scorecard in full, with each tool marked 1 to 5 on the five criteria. Prices are the published figures checked in November 2026, with Homebase Essentials at $24 a location a month on annual billing, and Deputy Lite at $5 a user a month.
| Tool | Starting price | Best for |
|---|---|---|
| Homebase | free for 1 location up to 10 employees; Essentials $24 per location a month annual | single-location hourly teams |
| Deputy | Lite $5 per user a month, Core $6.50, Pro $9; $30 monthly minimum | compliance-heavy hourly teams |
| When I Work | from $2.50 per user a month, reported | small teams that want the cheapest seat |
| 7shifts | free; paid from about $34.99 a month, reported | restaurants and cafes |
| Sling | free up to 30 users; Premium from $2 per user a month, reported | small teams that want a free start |
| Connecteam | from $29 a month, reported | teams that want an all-in-one app |
| Buddy Punch | from $2.99 per user a month, reported | teams that want a simple time clock |
| ZoomShift | from $2 per user a month, reported | small teams that want simple scheduling |
The 8 Tools in Detail
The eight tools below are ranked by the shift-work job they fit, from a cafe to a restaurant floor, and the top 10 hr software for hourly workers order puts the rota, the swap and the time clock first, not the brand.
1. Homebase
Homebase costs free for 1 location up to 10 employees; Essentials $24 per location a month annual, and it is built for single-location hourly teams. The first rotas built in Homebase, free for one location up to 10 employees, show the truth quickly: slower daily scheduling means a manager abandons the tool by the second month.
What stands out is Scheduling, time clock, hiring and messaging share one app, and the per-location price means a busy site pays the same as a quiet one. Put a live rota, time clock, hiring and messaging through Homebase for a week and the single app shows whether the per-location price suits a busy site as well as a quiet one.
The trade-off is Payroll is a separate add-on at $39 a month plus $6 per employee, and the free plan caps at 10 employees. Homebase charges payroll separately at $39 a month plus $6 per employee and the free plan caps at 10 employees, which is fine when known up front and a nasty surprise when found later.
Picture an hourly team on ten shifts a week in Homebase, saving 20 minutes on each shift. Over a month that is more than 13 hours with Homebase, close to two working days a manager can spend with the team instead of on rosters. Thirteen hours a month is what Homebase hands back to a single-location team.
For a buyer whose work matches single-location hourly teams, Homebase is worth a trial. The price of Homebase is free for 1 location up to 10 employees; Essentials $24 per location a month annual, the core job is solid, and the trial will show whether the limit matters to your work.
2. Deputy
Deputy is the compliance-heavy hourly teams option in this list, at Lite $5 per user a month, Core $6.50, Pro $9; $30 monthly minimum. Deputy is built for compliance-heavy hourly teams at Lite $5, Core $6.50 and Pro $9 per user a month, and a new user can still complete a first real task on day one.
The best part is Break rules, overtime flags and fair-workweek controls are built in, and the forecasting predicts demand well. Deputy’s built-in break rules, overtime flags and fair-workweek controls save a little time every day, and the demand forecasting adds more hours back across a month.
The catch is The per-user price climbs with every hire, and the $30 monthly minimum binds a team under six users on Lite. Use the Deputy trial to catch its hiring trap in week one, since the per-user price climbs with every hire and the $30 minimum binds a team under six on Lite.
Work a small example with Deputy. Deputy at 30 minutes saved a day over five days returns 150 minutes a week, or 10 hours a month a manager can give to the team instead of to rosters. At $25 an hour, that is $250 a month with Deputy, which is more than the subscription for most teams in this list.
Deputy earns its place for compliance-heavy hourly teams. At Lite $5 per user a month, Core $6.50, Pro $9; $30 monthly minimum Deputy is fair value, and the trial is the right way to test Deputy, because a week of real work says more than any review.
3. When I Work
At from $2.50 per user a month, reported, When I Work suits small teams that want the cheapest seat. When I Work’s screens are clear and the main features sit close at hand, which is right for a small team paying from $2.50 per user a month for the cheapest seat.
Here When I Work shines, because The entry price is the lowest per-user rate in this list, and the scheduling is simple to learn. At $2.50 a user, When I Work asks a small team to trade depth for the cheapest seat, so test the exact rota that strains it before paying.
The shortfall is The feature set is thinner than Deputy, and the compliance tools are basic. When I Work’s thinner feature set beside Deputy and its basic compliance tools should push a buyer to test the exact scheduling job that strains it before paying, rather than ruling it out.
Here is a worked example for When I Work. When I Work turns ten weekly shifts that each run 15 minutes faster into 150 saved minutes a week, about 10 hours a month. That is a day and a quarter of work When I Work saves, worth more than a day of labour at $2.50 per user a month.
If your work is small teams that want the cheapest seat, put When I Work on the shortlist at from $2.50 per user a month, reported. Run ten shifts through When I Work at $2.50 a user first, then probe where it strains before deciding.
4. 7shifts
7shifts at free; paid from about $34.99 a month, reported is aimed at restaurants and cafes. 7shifts covers scheduling, labour-cost tracking and team messaging for restaurants and cafes, with a real free tier and paid plans from about $34.99 a month.
The clear win is Scheduling, labour-cost tracking and team messaging are built for restaurants, and the free tier is real. A restaurant rota, labour-cost check and team message sharing one 7shifts screen makes the benefit obvious on first use, no sales call required.
The limit is The price is per location, so a multi-site team pays per site, and the payroll sync needs an integration. 7shifts bills per location, so a multi-site team pays for every site and the payroll sync needs an integration, which is worth weighing before calling the price low.
- 7shifts fits a restaurant or cafe team that wants scheduling running without a long setup before the next rota goes out.
- Run the next rota through 7shifts and check labour costs before the trial ends.
- 7shifts trades a deeper HR suite for hospitality scheduling from about $34.99 a month.
5. Sling
For small teams that want a free start, Sling at free up to 30 users; Premium from $2 per user a month, reported is a solid choice. Sling starts free for up to 30 users with Premium from $2 per user a month, and the short learning curve means a small team keeps using it after the first week.
The strength is The free plan covers 30 users, which is the most generous free tier in this list, and the scheduling is clean. Sling’s free plan covering 30 users earns its place in the daily scheduling a small team does, so judge it on that work, the job you run most often.
Ten shifts a week on Sling’s free plan, each 20 minutes shorter, gives a small team its time back. A month of that saving with Sling comes to more than 13 hours, most of two working days a small team no longer spends building rotas by hand. Sling’s free plan hands a small team two working days back each month.
Would this suit a small team?
Yes, Sling’s free plan for up to 30 users and its short setup let a small team start without a project plan.
What should I test first?
Run a real scheduling task in Sling first, then push it to its edge, because a free-start tool usually shows its weakness at the limit, not in the middle.
6. Connecteam
Connecteam costs from $29 a month, reported, and it is built for teams that want an all-in-one app. Run a real week of scheduling and time clock in Connecteam and time it: if the single app does not speed the day up, a manager will abandon it by the second month.
What stands out is Scheduling, time clock, forms and training share one app, and the mobile experience is strong. Run a real week of scheduling, time clock, forms and training through Connecteam and the single app shows its worth, helped by a mobile experience that holds up on the shop floor.
If your work is teams that want an all-in-one app, put Connecteam on the shortlist at from $29 a month, reported. Run one week of scheduling, time clock and training through Connecteam first, then test its edge.
7. Buddy Punch
Buddy Punch is the teams that want a simple time clock option in this list, at from $2.99 per user a month, reported. Buddy Punch is built for teams that want a simple time clock from $2.99 per user a month, and a new user can finish a first real clock-in task on day one without a manual.
The best part is The time clock is simple, with GPS and photo options, and the price is low. Buddy Punch’s simple time clock shaves minutes off each clock-in, and across a month of shifts those minutes turn into hours a team gets back.
For a buyer whose work matches teams that want a simple time clock, Buddy Punch is worth a trial. The price of Buddy Punch is from $2.99 per user a month, reported, the core job is solid, and the trial will show whether the limit matters to your work.
8. ZoomShift
At from $2 per user a month, reported, ZoomShift suits small teams that want simple scheduling. ZoomShift keeps its layout plain and puts its main features close at hand, so a small team that wants simple scheduling can start work without hunting through menus.
Here ZoomShift shines, because The scheduling is simple, and the price is low for a small team. ZoomShift’s simple scheduling and low price for a small team are the reasons it made this list, so give it a trial before settling elsewhere.
ZoomShift earns its place for small teams that want simple scheduling. At from $2 per user a month, reported ZoomShift is fair value, and the trial is the right way to test ZoomShift, because a week of real work says more than any review.
How to Choose Among the Top 10 HR Software for Hourly Workers
Start with the headcount and the site count, because the price model decides the bill. Homebase charges $24 a location a month on annual billing with unlimited employees, while Deputy charges $5 a user a month on Lite. A 12-person team on Homebase Essentials costs $24 a month, while the same team on Deputy Lite costs $60 a month, and on Deputy Core at $6.50 a user it costs $78 a month.
Then check the labour-cost view, because a rota that hides its cost is a rota that overspends. Homebase and 7shifts both show the labour cost beside the schedule, so the manager sees the week total before publishing. A tool without a labour-cost view lets the manager publish a rota that costs $500 more than the budget, and the discovery comes at payroll.
Finally, check the payroll sync. Homebase payroll is a separate add-on at $39 a month plus $6 per employee, while Deputy runs payroll through integrations. A team that retypes hours into payroll spends an hour a week on retyping, which is 52 hours a year. The sync is not a feature, it is an hour a week..
Homebase vs Deputy
Homebase wins the small-team round. It is free for one location with up to 10 employees, and Essentials costs $24 a location a month on annual billing with unlimited employees. A 12-person team pays $24 a month, which is less than half the Deputy Lite bill for the same team.
Deputy wins the compliance round. Its break rules, overtime flags and fair-workweek controls are the strongest in this list, and a team in a strict labour market needs them. The trade-off is price, because a 12-person team pays $60 a month on Lite and $78 on Core, and the $30 monthly minimum binds a smaller team.
What I would do is pick Homebase for a single-location team that wants the lowest bill, and Deputy for a team whose labour rules are strict enough to need the compliance depth. The trade-off is price against control, and a cafe that buys compliance depth it never uses has bought a heavier rota for a lighter job..
That is why the top 10 hr software for hourly workers decision comes down to Homebase for most buyers, with the runner-up winning only when its strength matches the job.
The No-Show on a Saturday Morning
The no-show comes on a Saturday morning, and the rota has no answer. A worker does not arrive, the team is short, and the manager has to find cover in an hour. The tool that helps here shows who is available, who has already worked their hours, and who can be called without breaking overtime rules. The tool that fails shows a rota and leaves the manager to phone around.
Homebase and Deputy both show availability and overtime beside the rota, so the manager can pick the right cover in minutes. The tools that fail are the ones that only show the schedule, because the schedule is the plan and the no-show is the problem with the plan. A rota without availability is a rota without an answer.
Work the numbers on a no-show. A team of 12 at $15 an hour costs $180 an hour, and a Saturday shift that runs short for four hours costs $720 in lost cover and overtime. A tool that finds cover in 10 minutes instead of an hour saves 50 minutes, which is $150 at the team rate. The no-show is not a staffing problem, it is a money problem with a rota attached..
A buyer comparing top 10 hr software for hourly workers should ask Homebase this question on the demo, because the answer reveals how the tool handles real work.

Can I Switch to Homebase Without Losing My Work?
Switching to Homebase works best as a staged move: get every schedule and timesheet out of the old system before the trial, then bring staff across in small groups. Get every schedule, timesheet and employee record out of the old system first, verify the export inside Homebase, and cancel the old subscription only after the records check out.
Next, run one live rota week in Homebase while the old system keeps running beside it for a week, so the comparison is real shifts against real shifts. Try one live rota week in Homebase with the old system still open, and only shift the following week across if that first week runs clean. Bringing staff across to Homebase in small groups keeps the old rota running beside it as backup.
What Should I Test Before I Pay for Homebase?
Begin with Homebase’s daily scheduling and time clock, because the rest of the system is worth little if that core work drags. Take one real rota from building it to publishing it in Homebase with real staff data, time it, and put that number beside the time the old system needed for the same week. A Homebase demo hides the awkward shift swap, since demo data is tidy and a real rota week is not.
Once the live week is done, push Homebase to its edge on purpose, since that is where a manager’s surprise usually hides, and a week-one discovery costs nothing. Find the Homebase task that strains its limits, such as the 10-employee cap on the free plan or a payroll edge, and ask the vendor what removing that limit would cost. Finding Homebase’s edge in week one costs a busy manager nothing.
How Much Will Homebase Cost in Year Two?
Homebase’s price in year two is the one to budget for, because the first-year discount, onboarding fee and introductory rate are gone. Homebase’s renewal price, how the rate moves with headcount, and whether payroll at $39 a month plus $6 per employee sits inside the base plan are worth confirming in writing.
Budget Homebase’s second year at the first-year price and the renewal will catch a small team out, so ask for that renewal figure in writing before the first bill even arrives. Get Homebase’s second-year invoice up front and read it against the first-year bill; that comparison, not the headline rate, decides whether the per-location price holds up over time.
Frequently Asked Questions
These answers cover the questions buyers ask most often about top 10 hr software for hourly workers, and the numbers above are the ones to check on the vendor page before buying.
How much does HR software cost for hourly workers?
Homebase is free for one location with up to 10 employees, and Essentials costs $24 a location a month on annual billing. Deputy Lite costs $5 a user a month, so a 12-person team pays $60 a month, and Core at $6.50 a user costs $78 a month. When I Work starts from $2.50 a user a month, reported.
Can hourly workers swap shifts in the app?
Shift swapping works on Homebase, Deputy, When I Work and 7shifts. The swap should need manager approval, and the rota should update at once. A tool that lets workers swap without approval leaves the manager finding out at 7 a.m. that the wrong person is on shift.
Does Homebase include payroll?
No, payroll is a separate add-on at $39 a month plus $6 per employee paid. The scheduling, time clock, hiring and messaging are in the base plans. A team that wants payroll in the base price should check Deputy, which runs payroll through integrations instead.
What is the cheapest HR software for hourly workers?
Homebase is free for one location with up to 10 employees, which is the cheapest route for a small team. Sling is free up to 30 users. Among paid per-user tools, When I Work starts from $2.50 a user a month, reported, which is the lowest paid seat in this list.
How do I handle time off for hourly workers?
The tool should let workers request time off in the app, show the manager the cover, and update the rota at once. Homebase and Deputy both handle this, with time-off balances beside the schedule. A tool without time-off tracking leaves the manager counting days in a spreadsheet.
Which tool is best for a restaurant?
7shifts is built for restaurants, with scheduling, labour-cost tracking and team messaging in one place. Homebase is close behind, and it is free for a single location with up to 10 employees. A restaurant with strict break rules should look at Deputy instead.
The Scorecard, Read Back
Homebase leads the scorecard. It scores 5 for free start, 4 for time-off handling, 4 for shift swaps, 4 for labour-cost view, and 3 for payroll sync, because payroll is a separate add-on. A 12-person team pays $24 a month on Essentials, which is the lowest paid bill in this list for a single location.
Deputy scores 3 for free start, 5 for time-off handling, 5 for shift swaps, 5 for labour-cost view, and 4 for payroll sync, and it is the pick for a team whose labour rules are strict. When I Work scores well on price at $2.50 a user, reported, and Sling scores well on its free tier for 30 users. Each one earns its place, and the scorecard shows why.
What I would do is start on Homebase free for a month, because one location with up to 10 employees costs nothing, and move to Essentials at $24 a month when the team grows past ten. A team that needs Deputy compliance can move later, and the move is easier when the rota already works. The scorecard says Homebase first, and the bill agrees..
That is the short version of this whole top 10 hr software for hourly workers comparison, and Homebase is the name to remember from it.
One More Thing to Check Before You Buy Homebase
One more check before buying Homebase is the support, because a tool is only as good as the help behind it when something goes wrong. In the Homebase trial, raise a real rota or time-clock question with support and clock the response, judging the reply on whether it fixes the problem or just points at a help page. A Homebase support answer landing the same day a shift gap opens beats a feature list, because the rota cannot wait for a slow reply.
Plan the Homebase exit before the entry: export sample schedules and timesheets during the trial and open them elsewhere, so a later move keeps every employee record intact. In the Homebase trial, pull out a few finished schedules and timesheets and open them outside the tool; complete files mean the exit works, broken ones are a warning. Sample schedules and timesheets that open cleanly outside Homebase prove the exit works before paying anything.
Homebase’s update rhythm is worth a third check: a tool that never updates falls behind, while one that changes every week breaks the rota workflow a team relies on. Skim Homebase’s last three months of release notes for fixes to the rota or hiring problems you care about, and judge from those notes whether the vendor listens to managers like you.
Homebase’s user community is worth a fourth check, since the best rota and hiring tips come from other managers running hourly teams, not from the vendor. Search for real managers talking about Homebase, read what they complain about, and see whether those complaints match the rota and hiring work you do. An active user community keeps Homebase improving, since real managers surface the rota and pay problems the vendor would otherwise miss.